Skip to main content
Beginning of main content

City Club Hotel

4.0 out of 5.0

Recent guest reviews

One of the best staffs ever, rooms very clean and supplied with the basic necessities.

Room was small, but comfortable and clean. It was very quiet and we slept great. The staff couldnt have been nicer and the nightly cookies were amazing. I will definitely stay here again.

Dingy small room with loud air conditioning unit and no natural light.

I'm very happy with my stay. Enjoyed everything. Very nice room.

While the hotel staff were nice, and the location was excellent, it has been a while since I have seen such a bad room.

GREAT LOCATION AND FRIENDLY AND HELPFUL STAFF. ROOM WAS CLEAN AND COMFORTABLE.

Had a little difficulty finding the hotel especially while we were driving since it only had CC on the door written. So we had to call the hotel and the staffs were more than willing to stay on the phone just to assist us get to the hotel. They have no valet but there are 2 parking garage close by. Their location is on the 44th street and between 5th and 6th. It's walking distance to broadway shows, empire state, cental park, time square and rockefeller. The old looks small and kinda older but for the price we paid $237/night for 5 people, they have the best rate, location, staff and it's pretty comfortable. They even gave us free cookies. The room is clean and I was pretty impressed with the bathroom. The beds are kinda lumpy and aircondition was weird. But I would definitely stay here again not just coz of the price!

The hotel is located in very close proximity to Times Square. The staff was very friendly and helpful (5 stars). The overall hotel room was just okay. Some of the features were a bit older and could use some updating. The bathroom door is located right next to the bed so it was a bit awkward.Not sure if I would recommend the hotel for the price I paid.

Granted this was my first hotel that I've been in while in NY. It was NOT a disappointment by any means. Wi-fi was stable, the room was simple/petite (mine anyways), but the bathroom was very modern/luxurious, the shower was nice, it has a bidet, the bathroom amenities are solid. The staff was generally helpful with recommendations and accommodations. Maybe it was because I had a petite/simple room..., I didn't have a desk/table or chair ... at times that was a bit inconvenient, there was a small 'desk/bed stand' but if you wanted to eat in your room and not eating on the bed or the floor... Overall, I was very pleased with my stay here, and would absolutely stay here again with any hesitations or reservations. But on that note, I would need to stay at other hotels to really compare with this one :-)

Perfect Boutique Hotel. Professional and friendly staff.

Loved the design and decor of the room. The staff was super friendly and helpful. Location very convenient(parking garage direct across street). I will definitely stay here again. I highly recommend it.

Place is deceptively nice. Everything is tiny until you hit the room. Very nice surprise once you are in the room. Very Comfortable. Only problem we had was with trying to get some extra towels. We had to ask 3 times. I am sure this is not a normal occurrence. The staff is very friendly.

Was in NYC 1 night for a show. Booked my flight and hotel together 3 days before I left. Couldn't be happier. Hotel and staff were great. Extremely nice hotel. Not much view but that's it for the negatives. Would stay there again.

Had a good stay at City Club Hotel though room was tight bathroom was spa like. Clean, quiet and great staff. They had umbrellas ready for us on rainy days!

Spacious room (king bed) and also had great water pressure.

Wish it had a coffee shop, but other than that it was great.

Top location, small room but very comfortable and great staff!

Excellent overall very pleasant / very clean/ very quite / very good for a good rest

Have stayed in this hotel before and enjoyed it, but this time was a disappointment. The room was petite which was so small, the bed was almost right against the door. There was a service closet beside the room with someone banging the door at 6am every morning. I mentioned it to staff twice but all they could say was a kinda sorry but tough. So in general was disappointed with it to be honest.

Room options

Luxury Room, 1 Queen Bed

Queen 1 | Sleeps 3

Luxury Room, 1 King Bed

King 1 | Sleeps 4

Duplex, 1 King Bed

King 1 | Sleeps 5

Family Room, Connecting Rooms

Queen 1 | Sleeps 6

Guest reviews for City Club Hotel

Everyone (9) Couples (37) Business (37) Family (26) Other (32) Friends (11)
5

great stay

Everyone

One of the best staffs ever, rooms very clean and supplied with the basic necessities.

By , from Miami, FL on Aug 8, 2017

5

great location right in the theater district.

Everyone

Room was small, but comfortable and clean. It was very quiet and we slept great. The staff couldnt have been nicer and the nightly cookies were amazing. I will definitely stay here again.

By , from San Rafael, CA on Jul 2, 2017

2
Everyone

Dingy small room with loud air conditioning unit and no natural light.

By on May 12, 2017

5

nice room. nice bed. nice bathroom

Everyone

I'm very happy with my stay. Enjoyed everything. Very nice room.

By , from New York. Ny on Jan 8, 2017

2
Everyone

While the hotel staff were nice, and the location was excellent, it has been a while since I have seen such a bad room.

By on Dec 11, 2016

5

perfect location and stay

Everyone

GREAT LOCATION AND FRIENDLY AND HELPFUL STAFF. ROOM WAS CLEAN AND COMFORTABLE.

By on Nov 21, 2016

4

good location, boutique but not perfect

Everyone

By , from Boston on Oct 31, 2016

4

best location

Everyone

Had a little difficulty finding the hotel especially while we were driving since it only had CC on the door written. So we had to call the hotel and the staffs were more than willing to stay on the phone just to assist us get to the hotel. They have no valet but there are 2 parking garage close by. Their location is on the 44th street and between 5th and 6th. It's walking distance to broadway shows, empire state, cental park, time square and rockefeller. The old looks small and kinda older but for the price we paid $237/night for 5 people, they have the best rate, location, staff and it's pretty comfortable. They even gave us free cookies. The room is clean and I was pretty impressed with the bathroom. The beds are kinda lumpy and aircondition was weird. But I would definitely stay here again not just coz of the price!

By , from NJ on Aug 31, 2016

3

great location and friendly staff

Everyone

The hotel is located in very close proximity to Times Square. The staff was very friendly and helpful (5 stars). The overall hotel room was just okay. Some of the features were a bit older and could use some updating. The bathroom door is located right next to the bed so it was a bit awkward.Not sure if I would recommend the hotel for the price I paid.

By , from Fairfax, VA on Jul 18, 2016

5

nice simple modern modest hotel

Singles

Granted this was my first hotel that I've been in while in NY. It was NOT a disappointment by any means. Wi-fi was stable, the room was simple/petite (mine anyways), but the bathroom was very modern/luxurious, the shower was nice, it has a bidet, the bathroom amenities are solid. The staff was generally helpful with recommendations and accommodations. Maybe it was because I had a petite/simple room..., I didn't have a desk/table or chair ... at times that was a bit inconvenient, there was a small 'desk/bed stand' but if you wanted to eat in your room and not eating on the bed or the floor... Overall, I was very pleased with my stay here, and would absolutely stay here again with any hesitations or reservations. But on that note, I would need to stay at other hotels to really compare with this one :-)

By on Feb 19, 2016