Hotels near Shelter Island

"This is a hotel that you stay for the wonderful ocean view,harbor and docking your boat. A must stay for us.Excellent chef! Happy hour Ahi Tuna …the best I have ever eaten! Staff very friendly and helpful. Bellhop very friendly and energetic to help with luggage. Beautiful park across the street,overlooking the ocean. "

"This hotel has so much potential but needs to do a few things to make it a great stay. Pros: it has some nice amenities, beautiful grounds, quiet location within walking distance to food, bars, nearby grocery store, and some nice waterfront walking. It has an onsite restaurant and bar. Parking is fairly secure. Cons: rooms are outdated, smell musty (some have cigarette smell), and walls are thin so you hear all the neighbors. Housecleaning was minimal and carpets and bathroom floors made bottoms of feet black from days, weeks… of non cleaning. Had to wear flip flops to prevent that. Amenities are very crowded and almost impossible to find pool chairs, space in pool, jacuzzi, fire pit. Families let their kids run all around and the rules of parental supervision posted are largely ignored. Suggestions would include using some of the space to build a kids pool, so adult couples can enjoy their own areas free of splashing shrieking, garbage, and saved pool chairs that sat empty nearly all day. Re training the cleaning staff to use a vacuum and mop bathroom floors, bathrooms in general, especially between guests. Update to all tile floors to eliminate moldy smells and repaint walls to get rid of cigarette smells in rooms (they sprayed air freshener when we complained). "

"The staff was so very friendly and accommodating as we were traveling to San Diego for a wedding and had my 88 year old mother with so they booked our room close to the lobby with the wonderful restaurant all close by for her to walk. Very scenic with the marina on one side and the bay on the other with great walking paths all around!"