Hotels near Shelter Island

"This cute hotel is a nice stop - especially if you’re wanting to explore their property on the water or pop in to see a show. As we checked in late on a weekday night, we could see the tiki fire-pit area, which was so fun and really lovely to explore. The room definitely left much to be desired… it smelled overpoweringly like an older woman’s musty perfume and gave me a headache all night. The beds were pretty uncomfortable- soft with no support, pillows also offered no support. The shower pressure was strong, and the provided bath products smelled refreshing and worked well. The entrance to our room was actually through the patio which was very weird (we were given a heads up by the kind front desk person, so all good, just still weird). Once we got the patio door open, there were wooden shutters directly behind that we had to battle to enter! It was awkward, but once inside, the shutters looked very beachy and a bit fun. I believe the property is a Mid-Mod era build, so I fully give it the historic nod, allowing for a bit of oddness and quirky design. Once we woke up and got a chance to explore the property, we fell in love with the birds and Koi, the cool concert green, and the fun pool and bar area (we had to get going so did not swim or order any food). Coffee from the machine in the lobby was actually pretty good (there was a small drip machine in the room, but honestly, I can’t do those in room machines anymore - 😝 iykyk)! Would stay again if we got a better room."

"The staff was great. The breakfast was excellent and well stocked that lady really made a difference in keeping it that way."

"Great location & clean. Parking can be difficult. Rooms are older and could use an update. Staff was nice. "