Historical Hotels in Mahwah, NJ

"Hotel was under renovation. We were informed prior that the pool was under renovation but not the entire hotel. Most of the 3rd floor was under construction. There were rooms on the second floor under construction. The carpets were dirty and WiFi was intermittent. Front desk was helpful and allowed us to cancel our reservation and provided a full refund. Perhaps it will be better in the future. "

"This was my first time staying on the 2nd floor. I would avoid for future trips. The bar on the 1st floor is either opened very late or they let customers sit there late into the evening talking very loudly. I was not notified that pool would be out for repairs when I made reservations. Kids were disappointed, but not a big deal. The ceiling lamp shade on top of the table in room just fell over on top of table. It is lightweight plastic, probably would not injure anyone if it did hit us, but the shade was clearly previously broken, as 2 of the 3 mounting hooks were cracked and missing. Why still give them 4 stars? I've stayed here multiple times, and none of this was normal compared to our previous stays. If it consistently stays like this, I won't be coming back."

"It was fine for a quick overnight stay. Room was nice. Breakfast was good could’ve used a few more varieties. Parking was great."