Skip to main content
Beginning of main content
 Islandia •1 Room
 Islandia • 1 Room
Book online or call 1-844-663-2276 Phone Number
< See all hotels

Jake's 58 Hotel & Casino

3.5 out of 5.0
Overview Reviews Amenities & Policies
3635 Express Dr N, Islandia, NY
1-844-663-2269
3.6
out of 5
Average Guest Review
See all 51 reviews
Room cleanliness 4.0
Service & staff 4.0
Room comfort 4.0
Hotel condition 3.5

This hotel is most popular for:

  • Everyone
  • Family
  • Couples

Recent guest reviews

This is an older building and could use a few updates. We did not have much interest in the casino so the review is more about the hotel. The elevator was very noisy and clanged several times on the way up and down. (That was a little unnerving). the rooms were adequate size, but had double (full) size beds. It seems that Queen beds would have fit just as easily and been much more comfortable. The rooms were cleaned daily and were satisfactory, although the toilets were not always cleaned.(The toilet was clean on arrival) Overall, I selected this hotel for location. I did not feel like it was a good value, and will likely select another hotel if queen beds are available.

rooms weren't made up daily, unless requested. Security blocks access to the car valet In the morning. This is a big inconvenience when checking out with baggage

This place is a dump. The only effort they put into cleaning is the slot machine areas. The rooms suck! get some new carpets and bathroom fixtures. The parking is HORRIBLE! At least have a parking area for guests staying multiple nights with a key card entry. Everytime I left it took me at least 30 minutes to find a parking spot when I got back. This place sucks and I travel alot so I have plenty of experience with hotels.

Resturant was something to be desired. Should be open for breakfeast.

Only stayed for one night for a wedding but the place was nice clean friendly and from being an out of Towner all the staff was great helping me out with the area

we,qa'vme'v,1 .wmqefvm:2e@lefV 1m/ e v;mvq'Elfmvq"Elmvq"ELf rqWQfweg e

I liked the small clothes line they had in the shower so you could hang and reuse towels/washcloths...just like at home. A number of the electrical outlets did not work properly... when plugging a plug into an outlet, the plugs would be loose, wobble or you had to move the plug just right to get it to work. The ice machine did not work. We had to go from floor eight to floor seven to get our ice. Our carpet was soak and wet in front of the TV and refrigerator area. With the hotel having a casino, it was difficult to find a parking place in the evening so it forces you to use the Valet Parking. While the hotel appeared to be well kept, the people were nice, and the restaurant foods were good, with these many issues or problems, one would expect the room prices to be that of a lower end hotel.

Hotel was ok. Casino and bar was good. Room was just a regular room but the room I stayed in was not clean. There were boogers (snot) on the inside of the shower curtain which turned me off and made me wonder about the rest of the bathroom. There were urine stains at the bottom of toilet. I did call the front desk and they sent a gentleman to clean shower curtain with a hand towel and no cleaner. The food I ordered from room service was pricey and just ok. Will not pay as much as I paid to stay here again.

The bed was very uncomfortable and small. I could never stay in the hotel again because of the beds.

The hotel has a nice small casino but when I checked in my room there were ants under the chair near the bed with crumbs and rugs were dirty. They moved us into the suite and there were dirty napkins behind the window curtains, the sheets felt musty and not clean , the rugs were dirty and the hotel is old. I would never stay here again! We didn’t get to the room till 4:30 in the morning and left first thing not to stay there to long.

The only downside is I was charged twice for my stay. They allowed duplicate charges for rooms to be charge to my bank account. As of yet I still have not been credited for the mistake. The hotel manager said that your company Orbitz is owned by Expida and you duplicate your reservation. Please help clear this matter up and return my funds.

Went to spend some quality couple time. Room upgrad d to suite on check in. Clean, quiet. Only disappointment was the rooms do not have coffee pots! All I wanted in morning was a quiet cup of coffee with my hubby!

Express Dr N Islandia NY

Hotel highlights

  • Free in-room WiFi
  • Free valet and self parking
  • Onsite dining
  • Casino

Located within a mile (2 km) of Lakeland County Park, Jake's 58 Hotel & Casino is within 3 miles (5 km) of Lake Ronkonkoma. This 227-room, 3.5-star hotel has a casino along with a 24-hour fitness center and free in-room WiFi.


Dining

Enjoy a bite to eat at Bistro 58, the hotel's onsite restaurant. Savor a meal from the comfort of your room with room service, or get a quick energy boost at the coffee shop/café. Start weekends with buffet breakfast, available for a fee from 8:00 AM to noon.


Rooms

All 227 air-conditioned rooms feature refrigerators, safes, and ironing boards. TVs come with digital channels, and free WiFi keeps guests connected. Bathrooms have hair dryers and free toiletries. Desks are also standard.


Property features

Guests staying at Jake's 58 Hotel & Casino enjoy access to a casino, a 24-hour fitness center, and WiFi in public areas. Free valet and self parking are available—or if you're not driving, take the free airport shuttle during limited hours. Front-desk staff can answer questions 24/7, and assist with luggage storage, securing valuables, and dry cleaning/laundry. Additional amenities include free newspapers, wedding services, and an ATM.

Room options

Room, 1 King Bed

King 1 | Sleeps 2
$180* Per night/room Nov 13 - Nov 14

Double Room

Full 2 | Sleeps 4

Room, 1 King Bed

King 1 | Sleeps 2

Guest reviews for Jake's 58 Hotel & Casino

Everyone (22) Couples (8) Business (6) Family (13) Friends (3) Other (3)
4
Everyone

By on Nov 5, 2019

Review comment responded on Nov 5, 2019

Thank you, we appreciate your feedback.

4
Everyone

By on Oct 1, 2019

Review comment responded on Oct 1, 2019

We appreciate your feedback, thank you.

3
Families Families

This is an older building and could use a few updates. We did not have much interest in the casino so the review is more about the hotel. The elevator was very noisy and clanged several times on the way up and down. (That was a little unnerving). the rooms were adequate size, but had double (full) size beds. It seems that Queen beds would have fit just as easily and been much more comfortable. The rooms were cleaned daily and were satisfactory, although the toilets were not always cleaned.(The toilet was clean on arrival) Overall, I selected this hotel for location. I did not feel like it was a good value, and will likely select another hotel if queen beds are available.

By on Jul 25, 2019

Review comment responded on Jul 25, 2019

Thank you, we appreciate your feedback.

2
Everyone

rooms weren't made up daily, unless requested. Security blocks access to the car valet In the morning. This is a big inconvenience when checking out with baggage

By , from Simi Valley California on Jul 25, 2019

3
Everyone

By on Jul 23, 2019

Review comment responded on Jul 23, 2019

We appreciate your feedback, thank you.

1
Families Families

This place is a dump. The only effort they put into cleaning is the slot machine areas. The rooms suck! get some new carpets and bathroom fixtures. The parking is HORRIBLE! At least have a parking area for guests staying multiple nights with a key card entry. Everytime I left it took me at least 30 minutes to find a parking spot when I got back. This place sucks and I travel alot so I have plenty of experience with hotels.

By on Jul 17, 2019

3
Everyone

By on Jul 1, 2019

Review comment responded on Jul 2, 2019

Thank you, we appreciate your feedback.

4
Everyone

By on Jun 24, 2019

Review comment responded on Jun 25, 2019

Thank you, we appreciate your feedback.

3
Families Families

Resturant was something to be desired. Should be open for breakfeast.

By on Jun 16, 2019

Review comment responded on Jun 16, 2019

We appreciate your feedback, thank you! We do have breakfast buffets on Saturday and Sunday mornings.

4
Partner Couples Families

Only stayed for one night for a wedding but the place was nice clean friendly and from being an out of Towner all the staff was great helping me out with the area

By on Jun 3, 2019

Review comment responded on Jun 6, 2019

Awesome, great to hear! :) We're glad you enjoyed your stay. We appreciate your feedback.

Jake's 58 Hotel & Casino

3635 Express Dr N, Islandia, NY 11749
url importing https://www.orbitz.com/Islandia-Hotels-Jake's-58-Hotel-&-Casino.h26698-p2.Hotel-Reviews