Skip to main content
Beginning of main content

Comfort Inn Presque Isle

2.5 out of 5.0

Recent guest reviews

Very clean, quiet, and has friendly staff!! Convenient shuttle service

The hotel really catered to the marathoners staying there. Along with having a message on their board welcoming the marathoners, they allowed late checkouts. The best part was that they had their breakfast ready 2 hours earlier, opening up at 4am! That worked out great for me, as I wanted to be done eating by 5am for the 7am marathon start. I look forward to staying at this hotel next year when I run the marathon again.

Great stay, great location, and great pool I would recommend it to anyone looking for an Erie hotel near the lake

We were very disappointed in our accommodation. They are doing renovations however, until they are complete it doesn't give you what is expected. Beds are incredibly uncomfortable. When I mentioned it to staff, they responded with "I know, we are replacing all the beds in our renovations". Well that does me no good right now.

Too warm in room.Air conditioner didn't work properly

Everything was very quiet and comfortable. The unit in our room only had low working when we like it to be cooler but it was still cool.

It was old, dirty and just plain run down. Was disappointed.

The hotel is close to Presque Isle where we were touring. The staff were friendly and helpful. The room was big and clean.

Erie is small but since there is limited taxi service, the park and fly option is less than leaving your car at the airport for a week. If you have an early flight, this is the way to go!

My wife and I stayed at this motel after a day of shopping and dining. The desk staff was friendly and polite upon arrival. The most impressive thing to us about this motel is how clean and fresh it was through out. We encountered no problems to speak of. The complimentary breakfast was ordinary. Overall,a much better place to stay than other motels in its class in the area. We`ll most likely stay again.

I travel to Erie every time. Sometimes more than once a year. I always stay at the Comfort Inn. In the future I will look for somewhere else to stay. The facilities get worse every time I visit. This time around the toilet in my room didn't flush and the exhaust fan in the bathroom wouldn't turn on. Add in a relatively high price and a staff that couldn't seem to care less and you end up with a place that doesn't deserve your money. The location is great but that's all that's left here.

Rooms are worn and outdated. Good location next to Presque Isle. But otherwise, not that great.

clean,good value, staff made every effort to make my stay positive .I certainly would return

Dirty carpeting in lobby and room, bedspread had a very large oil stain and also I didn't notice until morning a 3 inch blood smear on it. They need new mattress. Not enough room in breakfast area for all the people, and the Waffle iron , they only had one, the top heating element was burned out so half your waffle was raw and stuck and uneatable. There was not enough food for everyone there, The tables were dirty and sticky ,not being cleaned after people left. I travel to Erie once or twice a year, and I'll never stay here again.

We dropped into town and decided to find a place close to the water. Great value, clean, warm, friendly staff. Quaint little pubs near to eat and grab a drink. had a nice evening walk on the beach.

From Robb at the front desk to Todd the shuttle driver, 5 stars all the way. If I had a business I would hire them both right now. Both went out of their way ti insure we had a good stay. The hotel is a hotel, the staff will have have me coming back

We needed a good place to stay near the Erie International Airport. We had to get up very early for aflight the next morning. The room was clean, well stocked with towels and amenities, had great TV - entertainment center, and very friendly staff. They even woke us up on time! Great experience!

My experience at Comfort Inn Presque Isle was a pleasant one. The staff was friendly and helpful, the room was very clean, and the continental breakfast was plentiful and offered many options. No complaints at all, and I would definitely stay here again.

good night sleep in a comfortable setting. Very pleased.

Good breakfast and good hotel. I will stay this hotel at next trip.

3041 W 12th St Erie PA

Comfort Inn Presque Isle is located within a mile (2 km) of Tom Ridge Center and Waldameer Water World. This 100-room hotel welcomes guests with conveniences like free breakfast, an outdoor pool, and free in-room WiFi. Also near this Erie hotel are Lake Erie Arboretum at Frontier and Asbury Woods Nature Center.


Dining

Start your day off right with a free buffet breakfast.


Rooms

Comfort Inn Presque Isle's 100 rooms are air-conditioned and provide coffee makers, free local calls, and ironing boards. Guests can expect to find satellite TV and stay connected with free WiFi. Hair dryers and desks are also standard.


Property features

Guests of Comfort Inn Presque Isle enjoy an outdoor pool, free WiFi in public areas, and a seasonal outdoor pool. You can take advantage of free parking, along with a free airport shuttle (available 24 hours). The 24-hour front desk has staff standing by to help secure valuables, and answer any questions about the accommodations. This hotel also has laundry facilities.

Room options

Double Room, 2 Double Beds, Non Smoking

Full 2 | Sleeps 4

Double Room, 2 Double Beds, Smoking

Full 2 | Sleeps 4

Room, 1 Queen Bed, Accessible, Non Smoking

Queen 1 | Sleeps 2

Room, 1 King Bed, Accessible, Non Smoking

King 1 | Sleeps 2

Guest reviews for Comfort Inn Presque Isle

Everyone (5) Couples (15) Business (8) Family (12) Friends (4) Other (1)
5
Everyone

Very clean, quiet, and has friendly staff!! Convenient shuttle service

By on Mar 26, 2017

4

excellent for marathoners

Everyone

The hotel really catered to the marathoners staying there. Along with having a message on their board welcoming the marathoners, they allowed late checkouts. The best part was that they had their breakfast ready 2 hours earlier, opening up at 4am! That worked out great for me, as I wanted to be done eating by 5am for the 7am marathon start. I look forward to staying at this hotel next year when I run the marathon again.

By , from State College, PA on Sep 15, 2016

5

great breakfast and great pool

Everyone

Great stay, great location, and great pool I would recommend it to anyone looking for an Erie hotel near the lake

By , from P on Aug 23, 2016

2

wait till they complete their renovations.

Everyone

We were very disappointed in our accommodation. They are doing renovations however, until they are complete it doesn't give you what is expected. Beds are incredibly uncomfortable. When I mentioned it to staff, they responded with "I know, we are replacing all the beds in our renovations". Well that does me no good right now.

By , from Pittsburgh, PA on Aug 6, 2016

3
Everyone

Too warm in room.Air conditioner didn't work properly

By on Apr 24, 2016

4

very comfortable stay

Families

Everything was very quiet and comfortable. The unit in our room only had low working when we like it to be cooler but it was still cool.

By on Jul 1, 2015

2

won't book there again

GetawayWithFriends

It was old, dirty and just plain run down. Was disappointed.

By on Apr 21, 2015

3

great stay

Couples

The hotel is close to Presque Isle where we were touring. The staff were friendly and helpful. The room was big and clean.

By on Jan 21, 2015

4

great park and fly location

BusinessTravelers

Erie is small but since there is limited taxi service, the park and fly option is less than leaving your car at the airport for a week. If you have an early flight, this is the way to go!

By on Jan 14, 2015

3

overnight shopping trip

Couples

My wife and I stayed at this motel after a day of shopping and dining. The desk staff was friendly and polite upon arrival. The most impressive thing to us about this motel is how clean and fresh it was through out. We encountered no problems to speak of. The complimentary breakfast was ordinary. Overall,a much better place to stay than other motels in its class in the area. We`ll most likely stay again.

By on Nov 25, 2014