Skip to main content
Beginning of main content

Recent guest reviews

Very small room.not properly insulated that we can feel the wind and very cold weather from outside through the windows. Definitely needs some updating..saw several permits for construction posted on the door. Few blocks from Times square and subway is a big plus.

Very quaint. One elevator that is rickety enough to cause concern that it probably breaks down regularly enough. (Wasn't scary or a fear it would break down at anytime--just that it probably does happen.) Nice bathroom and good soap. Some room-specific disappointments show a potential overall lack-of-attention: clock wasn't plugged in and set (and the radio function broken); desk worklight inoperable; toilet seat did not stay up. Bed comfy and room, although tiny, is worth the tradeoff for location and price.

Excellent location and friendly staff. The conditions of the building need to improve because even that is clean does not look that way. Especially need to put attention to the bed sheets and covers.

Older building, but comfortable and clean, great location and price

Right in the middle of the theater district...very convenient. Needs some serious updating.

Great location, friendly staff, a great bargain in NYC. Right in the theater district and walking distance to great restaurants

The term well worn would be easily applied to this hotel. Though clean enough with very nice white, comfortable bedding the property itself has seen much use. Perfectly located in the theater district.

Property is outdated but the room I received was clean. Pillow covers do need replacement, they were brown and washed out due to age. Had to cover pillows with towels because I didn’t want my face touching them. Bathroom is fairly updated and AC was really nice. Overall it’s good for a night or two if you are looking for somewhere to lay your head.

Small room, A/C remote didn't work well. No coffee service. Otherwise, friendly and helpful staff, great location near Broadway.

Very central...conveniently walkable to all Broadway theaters...

Loved the quirky decor. Did not like that there was no vending machine.

I booked a double deluxe and it had a full bed, very uncomfortable for a couple. They should change the name, it is misguiding. I couldn't change to a room with a queen bed, because they didn't have one.

Tiny, European style circa 1940 room, just larger than the bed....cozy!

Location was GREAT! Right in the middle of the theatre district. This was a trip to "binge Broadway" for a weekend (three shows, two tours). We did not spend any time at the hotel other than to sleep, so this worked well for us. It is worn but clean, staff are nice. Room is adequate. don't need a car.

For visits to NY for Broadway shows, you cannot beat the location and price. The rooms are admittedly small and a bit tired, but they are clean and safe and when you're visiting NY, who's gonna spend a lot of time in their room?

W 49th St New York NY

Hotel highlights

  • Steps from Times Square and Gershwin Theater
  • Free WiFi in rooms and public areas
  • Onsite dining
  • 24-hour business center

Located in Midtown, Mayfair New York is next to popular attractions like Times Square and Gershwin Theater. This 78-room, 3-star hotel welcomes guests with a restaurant, free in-room WiFi, and a 24-hour business center.


Dining

Sit down for a leisurely bite to eat at the onsite restaurant, or enjoy a drink at the bar/lounge.


Rooms

Mayfair New York's 78 rooms provide safes, phones, and ironing boards. Guests can expect to find free WiFi and LCD TVs with cable channels. Bathrooms offer hair dryers and free toiletries.


Property features

Guests of Mayfair New York enjoy free WiFi in public areas, a 24-hour business center, and a porter/bellhop. Transportation is made easy with limo/town car service. The front desk has multilingual staff standing by 24 hours a day to assist with tours/tickets and luggage storage.

Room options

Standard Room, 1 Double Bed

1 Double Bed | Sleeps 2

Double Room, Accessible

1 Double Bed | Sleeps 2

Deluxe Room

1 Double Bed | Sleeps 2

Twin Room

1 Twin Bed | Sleeps 1

Guest reviews for Mayfair New York

Everyone (46) Couples (4) Students (1) Family (7)
2
Partner Couples

Very small room.not properly insulated that we can feel the wind and very cold weather from outside through the windows. Definitely needs some updating..saw several permits for construction posted on the door. Few blocks from Times square and subway is a big plus.

By on Feb 18, 2020

3
Business Business

Very quaint. One elevator that is rickety enough to cause concern that it probably breaks down regularly enough. (Wasn't scary or a fear it would break down at anytime--just that it probably does happen.) Nice bathroom and good soap. Some room-specific disappointments show a potential overall lack-of-attention: clock wasn't plugged in and set (and the radio function broken); desk worklight inoperable; toilet seat did not stay up. Bed comfy and room, although tiny, is worth the tradeoff for location and price.

By on Jan 18, 2020

3
Everyone

Excellent location and friendly staff. The conditions of the building need to improve because even that is clean does not look that way. Especially need to put attention to the bed sheets and covers.

By on Dec 1, 2019

4
Business Business

Older building, but comfortable and clean, great location and price

By on Oct 20, 2019

4
Everyone

By on Oct 20, 2019

3
Family

Right in the middle of the theater district...very convenient. Needs some serious updating.

By on Oct 2, 2019

5
Everyone

Great location, friendly staff, a great bargain in NYC. Right in the theater district and walking distance to great restaurants

By on Sep 17, 2019

4
Everyone

The term well worn would be easily applied to this hotel. Though clean enough with very nice white, comfortable bedding the property itself has seen much use. Perfectly located in the theater district.

By on Aug 19, 2019

4
Family

Property is outdated but the room I received was clean. Pillow covers do need replacement, they were brown and washed out due to age. Had to cover pillows with towels because I didn’t want my face touching them. Bathroom is fairly updated and AC was really nice. Overall it’s good for a night or two if you are looking for somewhere to lay your head.

By on Jul 21, 2019

4
Family Family

Small room, A/C remote didn't work well. No coffee service. Otherwise, friendly and helpful staff, great location near Broadway.

By on Jul 16, 2019

url importing http://www.orbitz.com/New-York-Hotels-Mayfair-New-York.h39715-p2.Hotel-Reviews
There was an error importing /New-York-Hotels-Mayfair-New-York.h39715-p2.Hotel-Reviews, error: javax.servlet.jsp.JspTagException: 301 http://www.orbitz.com/New-York-Hotels-Mayfair-New-York.h39715-p2.Hotel-Reviews