This Four Seasons has lovely staff and service and is in a fantastic location. We came to go to Liberty Island, and it was so convenient! The room was lovely, spacious, and thoughtfully prepared for 2 kids, including cupcakes, bubble bath, robes, and Four Seasons style local stuffies. The only complaint is the pool. It was cold cold cold, and a hot tub is conspicuously missing. That’s quite a drawback IMO, as our MO when we travel is to spend a lot of time in the hotel and especially in the pool! Didn’t have breakfast there - there’s an Olle and Stein across the street, and they have the best hot chocolate on the planet, so we went there each morning.