Skip to main content
Beginning of main content

Recent guest reviews

Being my first visit to the Florida Keys, I had a certain expectation and feel that I was looking for in my lodging. The Bay Harbor Lodge, did not disappoint! It was everything I imagined a charming little resort by the water should look like: cute bungalows, tropical landscaping, a palapa by the water's edge, and of course, friendly staff members. The gardener was kind and genuinely interested in talking with us about the landscaping.The office receptionist was a pleasure to interact with too. She made sure we had a pleasant check-in/out experience, she also helped us with using the peddle boat, and even brought some scones to our room for us to enjoy that evening, after returning from an early and long drive down to Key West and back again. We would stay here again in a heartbeat!

Been staying at Bay Harbor/Coconut Bay Resort for many years and it's still my go-to place in Key Largo. Friendly staff, clean accommodations, beautiful setting, and delicious homemade scones with your free morning coffee--what else could you ask for? The owner is continually doing upgrades to the property and the garden-like grounds receive daily attention. A great place to get the genuine Keys experience.

This was a commando mission to find a great place in Key Largo to wake up along the waterfront. I looked though the reviews and the place looked great, and the kicker was the scones. So I booked it. My flights were messed up, I arrived late after calling that I would be there. When I showed up, a nice note at registration, found my room in Cottage 3 and it was perfect. Exactly what I wanted. Met a few of the friendly neighbors and then went out to find some rum at the Caribbean Club. When I woke up, it was exactly as I had hoped. My cottage was in the perfect place, the coffee was fresh at 7:30 and the scones, yes the scones, the key lime, the cranberry, the strawberry. What a treat. They were branded Peg's Scones and then I met Peg, the owner and had a wonderful chat. I took a free kayak out into the water for an hour row, sat on the pier, enjoyed my scones, clean room, great air conditioning and this was just the perfect place. I will come back here again for sure. Book cottages 1-5 for the water view experience. The staff was great, the beds were comfy, bathrooms clean and the vibe was great. So glad I chose it, as when I went for my kayak, i say how jammed in some of the other places along this stretch were. Thanks Peg and crew for a wonderful time Also, there is a Denny's that has a bar 100 yards down the road for nearby cocktails, otherwise you are back to Key Largo. Stop and get booze and snacks before you get there.

This was our second visit to the Bay Harbor and we will definitely be back for a third! We come here when we want a nice relaxing vacation and has everything to make it perfect...beautiful gardens, free kayaking and paddle boarding, gorgeous sunsets and a nice pool. And every morning fresh baked scones from the owner Peg who does an amazing job with this property!

Great place to stay with it's own small beach on a beautiful cove, free use of kayak's, guest accommodation very good, would definitely recommend if you want a very nice relaxing holiday. Don't miss the Free coffee and scones available every morning. Staff on site are very helpful, lots of restaurants close by.

The rooms were accomodating.the beach was nice.the pool was a hit with the grand daughter as well as the kayack.The gardens wre my favorite with all the orchids.The staff was friendly.The sunset was great and the local restraunts was a hit.I can't wait till we go back.

I loved this place and I will definitely come back. The hotel has beautiful plants and landscape throughout the entire property. The room was clean and comfortable with AC and just as described on the website. The staff was friendly and welcoming. There was coffee in the morning served outside with their homemade scones. I came with my boyfriend for a little getaway and it was very relaxing and romantic.

Will definitely return-reasonable rates, clean rooms, kayaks and paddleboards for your use at no additional charge, fresh bakes scones and coffee each morning. Friendly, accommodating staff, most rooms have either a charcoal or gas grill for your use. This property has all the comforts of home.

Very clean, nice rooms with a charming look and feel. Loved the scones in the morning and sitting in the Tiki Hut with friends every evening. Water was beautiful, pool lovely - we would definitely spend a long weekend here again! Minutes from John Pennekamp for scuba and snorkeling.

We found this place on line and read all the reviews. We are so glad we booked here. It is a bunch of little cabins and then some units that were 1st and 2nd floor levels. Eric checked us in. He was so polite and kind. He recommended awesome places to eat! The fresh baked scones every morning were delicious! Our cabin was really clean! You had a small table and chairs to sit outside your cabin or you could sit under the tiki hut or by the water. There was a nice pool as well. There was free paddle boats or kayaking right there. We plan on going back and definitely staying here. We had 2 full size beds and the other coupe we were with had 2 queen size beds. They were on the 2nd level and we were in a separate cabin. We paid a tad bit more for ours but in my opinion, worth it!

Overseas Highway Key Largo FL

Hotel highlights

  • Free WiFi in rooms and public areas
  • Free parking
  • Private beach
  • Outdoor pool

Within a short walk of Bluefin Rock Harbor Marina, Bay Harbor Lodge is within 2 miles (3 km) of Dolphins Plus. This 15-room, 3-star lodge welcomes guests with conveniences like a private beach, an outdoor pool, and free in-room WiFi.


Rooms

The 15 rooms are air-conditioned and have microwaves and refrigerators. Guests can enjoy free WiFi and cable TV. Climb into the memory foam bed for a pleasant night's sleep.


Property features

Guests staying at Bay Harbor Lodge enjoy access to a private beach, an outdoor pool, and free WiFi in public areas. If you decide to drive, there's free parking. Front-desk staff can help with concierge services, and provide local restaurant recommendations. Other amenities at this beach lodge include free newspapers, a garden, and a picnic area.

Room options

Cottage, 1 Queen Bed with Sofabed, Kitchen (#03 Waterfront with Patio)

Queen 1 | Sleeps 4

Cottage, 1 Queen Bed with Sofabed, Kitchen (#01 Waterfront with Tiki Hut)

Queen 1 | Sleeps 4

Studio, 2 Queen Beds, Kitchen (#10 Poolside )

Queen 2 | Sleeps 4

Standard Room, 1 King Bed (#15 Balcony 2nd Floor)

King 1 | Sleeps 2

Reviews from Trip Advisor

Trip Advisor aggregated rating

93.0% of guests recommend this hotel

Total of 1039 reviews

url importing https://www.orbitz.comhttps://www.tripadvisor.com/Hotel_Review-g34344-d254304-Reviews-Bay_Harbor_Lodge-Key_Largo_Florida_Keys_Florida.html?m=13878
There was an error importing https://www.tripadvisor.com/Hotel_Review-g34344-d254304-Reviews-Bay_Harbor_Lodge-Key_Largo_Florida_Keys_Florida.html?m=13878, error: javax.servlet.jsp.JspException: Problem accessing the absolute URL "https://www.orbitz.comhttps://www.tripadvisor.com/Hotel_Review-g34344-d254304-Reviews-Bay_Harbor_Lodge-Key_Largo_Florida_Keys_Florida.html?m=13878". java.net.UnknownHostException: www.orbitz.comhttps