Hotels with a Pool in Shelter Island Heights, NY

"From the moment we arrived, we encountered a slight hiccup with our third-party booking. However, the manager was exceptionally helpful and went out of their way to ensure we had a room that met our needs and expectations. This personalized attention immediately set a positive tone for our stay. The room itself was modern and well-appointed. We were impressed by the updated amenities, including a convenient mini-fridge and microwave. The bed was comfortable, but the pillows were small and lacking in size. We wished they were larger and provided more support for a truly restful night's sleep. The bathroom featured a spacious walk-in shower, and we were delighted to discover a separate room with a powerful jacuzzi. The jets were impressively strong, providing a truly relaxing experience. An additional TV and a comfortable chair in this room were welcome extras that added to the room's appeal. Breakfast was a highlight of our stay. The spread was impressive, offering a variety of options including: - Cheese omelets - Gravy and biscuits - Waffle maker - Bagels and bread - Pastries - Individual oatmeal packages Overall, my husband and I thoroughly enjoyed our stay. Considering the excellent service, comfortable accommodations, and great value for the price, we wholeheartedly recommend this hotel to other travelers."

"Beautiful, perfect location. Garden room was wonderful. Food amazing. Staff welcoming and friendly. Can’t wait to return!"

"Amazing stay; they accommodated early checkin for us. We were able to use bikes on the property and the food at Ocean Club restaurant was really good. Both indoor and outdoor pools were open on May 10th. Will definitely return back."