Skip to main content
Beginning of main content

Recent guest reviews

I feel compelled to share our experience at this place. At first glance, the place has a cute appearance and much character. It is old but the concept is very cool. Check in staff were very nice and when we got to our 1 bed cottage, room 411, my Wife looked at me and was so excited. It looked like a little cute cottage until we walked inside. I was so disgusted and disappointed, and my Wife was appalled. This cottage was completely disgusting. It was dirty and gross. The bed frames were covered in some type of gunk, the walls were damaged, the floor was sticky, the blinds on the windows were rusted or mold on them. A complete DIVE. We didn't want to make a big deal of this due to it being our anniversary get away from Tampa Florida. I can only sum this place up as a "flop house". I am still so upset over this place. The people were weird, and my Wife said this place is a "HOSTILE". I did see a video on you tube about this place, but I chose to ignore it. I would love to get my money back because this place was NOT worth what I spent for two days. SO, I CAUTION YOU! This is not a place for a romantic getaway of any kind. Sorry for this review, but I couldn't wait to share when we got home. Sorry NYAH, this is CERTAINLY "Not Your Average Hotel. It is a BELOW AVERAGE HOTEL AT BEST.

12

Friendly staff, fun crowd. I loved the 3 pools and all the hidden picnic tables. Definitely go back again.

I liked that it was close to just about everything. Only dislike was having what seemed to be a maze getting to my room, my wheelchair.

Great staff, property was slightly outdated, but was in the process of updating pavers around pool area.

Great place for the price! Comfortable beds, clean rooms. Very friendly staff. Love the pool options.

Front door slammed and made a large noise. Room was small and confining.

Beautiful quiet neighborhood, wonderful staff, nice pool area. Within walking distance to everything.

Perhaps I didn't read the description very well, but I was surprised when I found out that I was in a shared room. Seems like the description is now clearer than I remember it being earlier. Nice place, but that was a surprise when I checked in.

Friendly staff

Check in took 30 min for two groups. Sheets were stained on the bed.

Air conditioning was broken in our room & They gave us another room. Thanks, Hope to see you again soon.

I like the free continental breakfast each morning and the 4 pools. I didn't really like the off site parking, but that's Key West, not NYAH.

Very clean place and personal very friendly

Margaret Street Key West FL

Hotel highlights

  • Walking distance to Duval Street
  • Free continental breakfast
  • Bar/lounge
  • 3 outdoor pools

Located in Key West Historic District within a short walk of Duval Street, NYAH Key West - Adults Only is within 2 miles (3 km) of other popular sights such as Mallory Square. This 35-room, 3-star guesthouse welcomes guests with 3 outdoor pools, free breakfast, and a spa tub.


Dining

Start your day off right with a free continental breakfast, served each morning from 8:00 AM to 10:30 AM. At the end of the day, the bar/lounge is a great place to grab a drink.


Rooms

Guests can expect to find 46-inch flat-screen TVs with cable channels. Hair dryers are also available.


Property features

3 outdoor pools, a rooftop terrace, and a spa tub are featured at NYAH Key West - Adults Only. The front desk has multilingual staff standing by 24 hours a day to assist with concierge services and luggage storage. Other amenities at this adults-only guesthouse include coffee/tea in a common area, a terrace, and a water dispenser.

Room options

NYAH Cottage 1 King Bed

1 King Bed | Sleeps 2

NYAH Private Room 4 Single Beds

4 Twin Beds | Sleeps 4

NYAH Private Balcony Room 6 Single Beds

6 Twin Beds | Sleeps 6

NYAH Private Loft 1 King and 2 Single Beds

1 King Bed and 2 Twin Beds | Sleeps 4

Guest reviews for NYAH Key West - Adults Only

Everyone (25) Couples (3) Family (14)
1
Partner Couples

I feel compelled to share our experience at this place. At first glance, the place has a cute appearance and much character. It is old but the concept is very cool. Check in staff were very nice and when we got to our 1 bed cottage, room 411, my Wife looked at me and was so excited. It looked like a little cute cottage until we walked inside. I was so disgusted and disappointed, and my Wife was appalled. This cottage was completely disgusting. It was dirty and gross. The bed frames were covered in some type of gunk, the walls were damaged, the floor was sticky, the blinds on the windows were rusted or mold on them. A complete DIVE. We didn't want to make a big deal of this due to it being our anniversary get away from Tampa Florida. I can only sum this place up as a "flop house". I am still so upset over this place. The people were weird, and my Wife said this place is a "HOSTILE". I did see a video on you tube about this place, but I chose to ignore it. I would love to get my money back because this place was NOT worth what I spent for two days. SO, I CAUTION YOU! This is not a place for a romantic getaway of any kind. Sorry for this review, but I couldn't wait to share when we got home. Sorry NYAH, this is CERTAINLY "Not Your Average Hotel. It is a BELOW AVERAGE HOTEL AT BEST.

By on Feb 12, 2024

5
Family

12

By on Nov 26, 2023

Review comment responded on Nov 29, 2023

Thank you so much for your feedback! We are happy that you enjoyed your stay and had a beautiful experience! Looking forward to seeing you again!

5
Everyone

Friendly staff, fun crowd. I loved the 3 pools and all the hidden picnic tables. Definitely go back again.

By on Oct 29, 2023

Review comment responded on Nov 29, 2023

Thank you for taking time to post your review. I'm glad you enjoyed our pools and the amenities that we offer. Please keep us in mind the next time your travel plans bring you back to Key West.

5
Everyone

I liked that it was close to just about everything. Only dislike was having what seemed to be a maze getting to my room, my wheelchair.

By on Sep 15, 2023

5
Everyone

By on Aug 10, 2023

5
Everyone

By on Mar 7, 2023

5
Everyone

Great staff, property was slightly outdated, but was in the process of updating pavers around pool area.

By on Feb 26, 2023

5
Family

Great place for the price! Comfortable beds, clean rooms. Very friendly staff. Love the pool options.

By on Feb 11, 2023

2
Friends

Front door slammed and made a large noise. Room was small and confining.

By on Jan 23, 2023

5
Partner Couples

Beautiful quiet neighborhood, wonderful staff, nice pool area. Within walking distance to everything.

By on Jan 22, 2023

NYAH Key West - Adults Only

420 Margaret Street, Key West, FL 33040
url importing http://www.orbitz.com/Key-West-Hotels-NYAH-Key-West---Adults-Only.h7500588-p2.Hotel-Reviews
There was an error importing /Key-West-Hotels-NYAH-Key-West---Adults-Only.h7500588-p2.Hotel-Reviews, error: javax.servlet.jsp.JspTagException: 301 http://www.orbitz.com/Key-West-Hotels-NYAH-Key-West---Adults-Only.h7500588-p2.Hotel-Reviews

Frequently asked questions