I can't give this property 5 stars, as much as I know they'd like it. In my mind a 5-star review requires a 5-star experience, which we just didn't have. Let's break down the good and the bad though.
The Good:
* Location: This is right off of the main highway (we didn't hear any of the traffic from inside though), it was easy to get to restaurants and to yellowstone from here.
* Beds: One reviewer said they only felt there were 2 bedrooms.. that is completely false, there are most certainly 4 bedrooms, we had 2 kids per bed in each room and it worked out great.
* Internet: Of course YS doesn't have cell service so it was nice to come back to some fast internet to take care of a few things and to stream a Disney movie for the kids Friday night.
* Outside: The outside patio has a bunch of comfortable chairs that we enjoyed hanging out on while the kids played in the empty lot next door.
The 3-4 star items:
* For the cost of the place, I would have expected the house to be better maintained. The downstairs bedroom had 2-3 missing blind panels, (kinda defeats the purpose of closing the light out). The light fixtures in the basement were missing, (only the light bulbs in but the rest of the fixture was gone), many outlets were loose when plugging in phone chargers they'd fall out, several outlet covers broken where you can see back into the wiring (not good when you have toddlers that like to stick their fingers everywhere), all the electronics for the tv in the main room are sitting on the fireplace bricks down low (cables just look messy and toddlers get into it). Front door has a bunch of puncture spots (not all the way through but you can see that it's not nice), etc.
* when we got there there was still a blue cleaning glove and sponge in the sink from the cleaners (not a big deal, things happen).
But like I said, for a 5-star review it should be a 5-star experience, I did not feel like the owners have been maintaining the building sufficiently for the price they charge.
That being said, we were comfortable and we had a great trip. If you look around at the other accomodations for the area, it's probably pretty on-par in terms of upkeep, but I expected a bit more.