Everything was wonderful…only complaint was the beds…I called the hotel to see what size they were for a double room and was told queen but they were fulls…not very comfortable for 2 kids and 2 adults.
The staff are great especially carry and oscar. 5-star service.
The property has beautiful views and lots to do onsite. The docks are a great place to walk after dinner and see all the yachts. The pool is too small to accommodate everyone and the beds were short. I am 5’9 and my feet were hanging off the end of the bed.
The property is on a secluded little island far away from everything. The Gurney's Montauk Resort is much more happening, like a Miami or Vegas scene. This Star Island one is for people who like absolute quiet. We stayed in the villas which are super nice and far from the actual hotel, but need some serious updating. The bathrooms do not look like they have been updated in decades. Overall a great set of hotels. Must go between the two as the Montauk one has the beach. The should really consider selling to Marriott to add to their Collection line.
Beautiful brand new facility. Excellent restaurants
Great amenities. Beautiful place. Highly recommended
Staff was exceptional. Resort was clean. A very positive experience. I will definitely return.
Loved the views and rooms. Restaurant was fabulous. Morning take and go - bad service. Front desk and cocktail lounge - great service Workout facility - disappointing in size and in need of updated equipment.
It is newly renovated and certainly not finished with smells of fresh paint or wood all over the place. They still have a lot of work to accomplish before the summer season starts.. There was just a lot of work and contractors all over the place during our stay. Nonetheless the staff was very nice, apologetic and very accommodating trying to deliver above and beyond service at every step of the way..
Very accommodating staff, gorgeous views , However facilities are datied and desperate need of updating
This resort is excellent - an oasis of calm in the middle of what can be a chaotic Montauk. The pool, the firepit, the outdoor bar and all of it - made for an excellent weekend.
Super cute clean with lovely views, comfortable & quiet weekend away. Love the property. Staff was pleasant and attentive....room was spacious. Only thing that didn’t cooperate was the weather but made the best of it!
My wife and I along with our new (3-month old) baby, booked a night at this hidden gem on the tip of Long Island. We wanted somewhere we could relax away from the hustle and bustle of everyday life – and that is what we (baby included) got! The room was spacious, clean and relaxing (loved the nautical theme and feel!). The view from the oceanfront/beach room was breathtaking and extremely relaxing…we sat on the porch breakfast-time for almost 2 hours sipping on our coffees, enjoying the gorgeous scenery and horizon. The sun was shining and not a cloud in sight, almost felt a scene from Bermuda. In short, we were very happy with our stay. Unfortunately, the pool was closed and had limited hours (open from 11:30am - 8pm). We were visiting off-peak season so, understandably there were some limitations to pool and bar hours, but that didn’t bother us much as the benefit of the serene, hushed and relaxing hotel offset any such limitations. I would recommend staying here if you’re looking for a quiet getaway. Great value for the price.
We loved the nautical theme that the hotel had. Rooms were clean and comfortable. Parking was super close to the rooms so that was nice. We did not stay long until he area but next time we do we would absolutely rebook with this hotel.
Came here expecting high end stuffy yacht club. Instead, we found a nice relaxing place. We are from CA and are not use to the NY personalities, so we didn't know how to take attitudes. However, we adjusted and enjoyed out stay. Thw food at the restaurant was great! The rooms were nautical and comfortable.
Beds are too soft. A/C was too hot or too cold and blowing straight onto the bed. Weather was lousy during our stay so that might have con
What we like about our visits to MYC is the layout of the property. Not only fine dining at your convenience, but, also, breakfast and lunch being offered, as well. The staff from top to bottom couldn't be nicer or more accommodating. From the initial greeting by the doorman, to the registration desk, etc., we felt that we truly were "welcome" - not just a standard script reading acknowledging our arrival. We plan on visiting again at some point this summer. It is a trip that is high on our priority list. Thank you to all of the staff/and management for making our stay truly enjoyable!
Hotel staff was extremely unhelpful and unaccommodating. Hotel offers free shuttle and in all of our recent stays (we've visited once a year for the past four years), during the off season, the shuttle will also take us to the golf course which is slightly over a mile away. We were told that the shuttle will absolutely not pick us up because it is not part of the route -- during the SECOND call to the hotel after we were told it was on its way. Then, when we called for a pick up, the staff had no idea what Gosman's was even though it is one of the two stops on the shuttle. To add insult to injury, we then took the shuttle into town and had to wait over 45 minutes for a pick up even though the town is less than a 10 minute drive away. We've always enjoyed our stay here but will never stay here again after this visit.
Montauk Yacht Club places you within a 5-minute walk of Lake Montauk and The Hamptons Beaches. This 107-room, 4-star hotel has 2 outdoor pools along with a private beach and a marina.
This hotel is home to 2 onsite restaurants, perfect for a quick bite to eat. Savor a meal from the comfort of your room with room service, or make new friends over drinks at the bar/lounge. Start each morning with cooked-to-order breakfast, available for a fee from 7:00 AM to 10:00 AM.
37-inch LCD TVs come with satellite channels, and guests can stay connected with free WiFi. Beds sport down comforters and bathrooms offer hair dryers and free toiletries. IPod docks, refrigerators, and coffee makers are also available.
Montauk Yacht Club features a private beach, a marina, and 2 outdoor pools. There's free parking and a free area shuttle. The front desk has multilingual staff on hand 24/7 to help with concierge services, luggage storage, and securing valuables. If you like to take your furry friend along on your adventures, this pet-friendly property offers food and water bowls. Other amenities at this beach hotel include an indoor pool, a gym, and outdoor tennis courts.
Everything was wonderful…only complaint was the beds…I called the hotel to see what size they were for a double room and was told queen but they were fulls…not very comfortable for 2 kids and 2 adults.
Hi Alison,Thank you for the review. We do apologize for the confusion with the beds. We hope to host you again!
The staff are great especially carry and oscar. 5-star service.
Thank you for choosing to stay with us and we are glad that you enjoyed your time here! We agree that Kerry and Oscar are amazing and we are all looking forward to welcoming you back next year!
The property has beautiful views and lots to do onsite. The docks are a great place to walk after dinner and see all the yachts. The pool is too small to accommodate everyone and the beds were short. I am 5’9 and my feet were hanging off the end of the bed.
Thank you so much for staying with us! Our apologies about the pool capacity, we do try to ask our guests to limit how long they are there to accommodate all of our guests. Additionally the rooms with two double beds are not large enough for queen beds that would be longer. We hope to see you again in the future!
The property is on a secluded little island far away from everything. The Gurney's Montauk Resort is much more happening, like a Miami or Vegas scene. This Star Island one is for people who like absolute quiet. We stayed in the villas which are super nice and far from the actual hotel, but need some serious updating. The bathrooms do not look like they have been updated in decades. Overall a great set of hotels. Must go between the two as the Montauk one has the beach. The should really consider selling to Marriott to add to their Collection line.
Thank you for staying with us and we are so happy that you enjoyed your stay here! The Villas are slated for a renovation in the next year, and you will have to rejoin us to see how they look! Hopefully we will see you again soon, and if you book again this year we do have rooms that have been newly renovated in the main area of the hotel!
Beautiful brand new facility. Excellent restaurants
Great amenities. Beautiful place. Highly recommended
Staff was exceptional. Resort was clean. A very positive experience. I will definitely return.
Loved the views and rooms. Restaurant was fabulous. Morning take and go - bad service. Front desk and cocktail lounge - great service Workout facility - disappointing in size and in need of updated equipment.
Hi Alex,Thank you for the great review! We hope to see you again!