Skip to main content
Beginning of main content

Mill Creek Hotel

2.5 out of 5.0

Recent guest reviews

This charming, quiet hotel is located in a lovely setting just steps from downtown and the lake. We enjoyed our stay in the very clean well-equipped suites. Great staff.

Hotel is right in the center of downtown Geneva convenience to the shops and the beach. Continental breakfast has a little bit to be desired.

Huge room. Very clean. Steps away from the beautiful lake and great shopping. Plenty of dining options all around. Perfect location.

Painless check in. Beautiful room. Very quiet. Within walking distance to everywhere. Awesome breakfast.

I booked as a last minute trip. The hotel and staff were perfect. Had a great weekend. Will stay there again.

I arrived early but while I waited I decided to venture out and do some shopping I could not believe how I was so close to everything ; I was able to get upgrade and I was impressed with how clean the room was and it was spacious I liked the decor of photographs of Lake Geneva There were extra added touches that made you feel special:the only drawback the bed was not real comfortable and my room faced street but being on 3rd floor helped & by bedtime the noise of outside faded

We stayed at this hotel, choosing it over all the other Lake Geneva hotels, based on the reviews on here. As we pulled up to the hotel, we were excited to see that the location is GREAT. It's right in town, 1 block from Geneva Lake, and Starbuck's is across the street, super convenient for grabbing that morning coffee and a breakfast snack. And since you're in town, it's only a short walk to several other restaurants. The other reviews were exactly right - If you're looking for a clean room, friendly staff who genuinely care about your stay experience with them, and want a great location in town, this is THE place to stay. The "Help Yourself to As Many as You Want" (said the check-in person) Andes chocolate mints by the check-in area are an added little bonus. All the rooms are actually suite-sized, with a bedroom separate from the living room and kitchen. They even include utensils. Each room has 2 bathrobes for your use as well. We had the cheapest room category - the Bronze - on the first floor - and loved it - The Silver and Gold suites are bigger and have better views - some or all with views of the woods. This is a place that grows more and more on you, the longer you stay. Don't be put off by the non-descript parking area for the hotel, and elevator/lobby area, as these are very basic. All the comforts of home while away from home, are here. The front desk staff are genuine and went out of their way to help and offer suggestions about the area. I would not hesitate to return. I highly recommend.

Stayed for one night and had a fabulous time. Hotel room is very spacious and quiet. Would definitely stay again.

Enjoyed a getaway weekend with my girlfriend at the Mill creek hotel. The room was awesome, loved the space, electric fireplace, and 2 person whirlpool jet tub. The hotel is located right downtown so close to great shops and excellent dining. We had a great stay and will be back...

The location of this property can't be beat - right off downtown and a block from the lake. The property is starting to show it's age, but it was clean and comfortable. I would return.

Location was perfection for walking to lake, shopping, to restaurants,etc. The staff was very nice; room clean, quiet; plenty of towels; frig kept drinks cold; coffeemaker worked. We only stayed one nite as were traveling but would stay here again bcause the location was perfect but would ask for a room with lake view. Rooms have small balcony but ours overlooked rooftops, parking lots,etc so didn't use. Guest parking was convenient.

The furniture was a little industrial, but the jacuzzi tub was amazing!

Very comfortable right within walking distance of all action

The only problem that I experienced with this hotel is that I had a room that was on the street side. I was awoken early every morning with garbage trucks or delivery trucks. I would recommend that anyone booking this hotel ask for a room that is not on the street side.

Our accomidations were very comfortable and the was friendly and helpful. The Hotel is located within walking distance to many eating places and just off main street, which is great access to the shops. Lake Geneva is with in walking distance alos.

The hotel is exactly as it is advertised. Very nice room with everything you would ever need. Very clean and very close to the lake. View was a little disappointing but not bad. Except for a couple of clogged drains it was a very nice stay.

The hotel was beautfuil, can't beat the location. The staff was wonderful and very helpful. My only complaint was that our room was by the street and we got alot of street noise late at night. We also were right by the post office and 5:30am Sat morning the post office trucks woke us up. The mattress was also very uncomforable. So, except for the lack of sleep we loved the hotel and will stay there again. we will request a room on the other side of the hotel.

Good location and value. One block off Main Street shopping and an easy walk to the lake. Full kitchen in unit would be good for extended stay. Full size jacuzzi tub in bathroom. Staff was very friendly and had plenty of suggestions for dining within walking distance. Small indoor pool and hot tub.

Three sisters sharing themselves with each other. We missed not having an oven to cook our one large dinner. The facility and its amenities met our expectations and we enjoyed visiting the local businesses. It would have been nice not to have been on the street side and gettin the early morning mail delivery back up or heavy traffic sounds.

Great place to stay. Very close to everything.