If you are looking for a campsite athmosphere, and historic cabins, meaning old, badly maintained and small cabins (we stayed in Tumble Inn), then this is the place to stay.
The surroundings are beautiful, the lake water is clear and brown (due to the woods) and hiking trails are easy to reach.
Positive: after initial complaint, the friendly staff spent two hours to clean the cabin and the windows, which improved our stay a lot.