8/10 Good
Jolene O.
Feb 16, 2026
We were truly looking forward to the stay on Stocking Island but in the end it was not for us.We were grateful for Allison and Norman’s responsiveness and kindness throughout and when we decided to leave early, Allison handled it with integrity; The location is somewhat isolated with access to food, beaches, and activities that depend on coordinating a water taxi (50 RT) from Great Exuma or renting a skiff at 300/day. The taxi does not run on a set schedule and stops at dark, which made meals and daily logistics a bit complicated. (kayaking might be an option but it was a chilly/rough seas during our stay).We rented a skiff for a day (loved Minn’s), the highlight of our trip, but at least for us, consistent boat access is essential to fully enjoy this location.The open windows, harbor views, covered deck, and fresh breeze were lovely. However, the cabin itself is weathered and in need of maintenance and updates; which I was told is in process. You can walk to the beautiful and wild Atlantic side, watch the sunsets from the covered decks, and there is a hiking trail to Coconut Club for a lovely day by the Caribbean. Beyond that, beach access is limited without a boat.In the end, we found ourselves spending more time coordinating transportation and meals than relaxing, which led us to shorten our stay.This property may be a great fit for travelers seeking true remoteness, boat-based access, and a true cabin by the harbor feel.
Jolene O.
Stayed 6 nights in Feb 2026















