Our family enjoyed our stay. We had two adults and three teens. Our mature teens loved easily walking to the horseshoe to grab quick bites and shopping = parent relaxation! We rented bikes but were so close to everything, that we didn't use them. The secret garden was terrific, thank you!
Drawbacks (which are few): all 3 kids had to share a bathroom, some fixtures are dated, there are limited linens such as towels/blankets, no laundry tabs/trash bags, older washer/dryer, and most importantly there were no comfy loungers/chairs on the decks. There were nice Adirondack chairs, however, no cushions or lounge chairs to lay back and watch the spectacular view. Additionally, there weren't any beach items included such as extra beach chairs, wagon, boards and such.