Skip to main content
Beginning of main content

Recent guest reviews

Attractive

Beautiful building with an extra friendly staff. Wonderful experience!

Nice but outdated and nothing special about this hotel. Not having a coffee maker in the room or a microwave stand out among the poor amenities. Pool was "open" but dirty and unheated. And no dining room. Continental breakfast was extremely limited although included in the price of the room, did not justify the amount charged. The balcony was nice and overlooked the harbor. On the plus side, It was quiet and easy walking distance to the town. Staff was pleasant.

Location and hospitality

Na

Great location. Right across from marina and close to Main Street.

very clean. Rooms recently re-done. Nice view from room

Beautiful, quaint & clean hotel. Great location by the water and walking distance to the Main Street with restaurants and shops. I would definitely come back here again!

Great atmosphere, perfect hotel for families. I will definitely return.

West Water Street Sag Harbor NY

Hotel highlights

  • Free continental breakfast
  • Free in-room WiFi
  • Free parking
  • Outdoor pool

Sag Harbor Inn places you next to The Hamptons Beaches and within a 10-minute walk of Bay Street Theatre. This 3.5-star hotel welcomes guests with 42 rooms and conveniences like an outdoor pool, free in-room WiFi, and free self parking.


Dining

Start your day off right with a free continental breakfast, served each morning from 7:00 AM to 10:30 AM.


Rooms

Guests can expect free WiFi and flat-screen TVs with cable channels. Bathrooms have hair dryers and free toiletries. Other amenities include balconies or patios, free long-distance calls, and free local calls.


Property features

Sag Harbor Inn offers an outdoor pool, a seasonal outdoor pool, and coffee in a common area. Free parking is available if you drive. The 24-hour front desk has staff standing by to help with luggage storage, and answer any questions about the accommodations. Additional amenities include a meeting room, a vending machine, and a fireplace in the lobby.

Room options

Poolside Two Full Beds 2nd Floor

2 Double Beds | Sleeps 4

Harborview King Bed 2nd Floor

1 King Bed | Sleeps 3

Poolside Queen Bed 2nd Floor

1 Queen Bed | Sleeps 2

Harborview King Bed 1st Floor

1 King Bed | Sleeps 3

Guest reviews for Sag Harbor Inn

Everyone (8) Couples (5) Family (2)
5
Friends

Attractive

By on Oct 21, 2022

Review comment responded on Oct 22, 2022

Hello Bette,Thank you for staying with us, and thank you also for your review of our hotel. We hope you've had a wonderful experience as our guest.We thank you again for choosing Sag Harbor Inn, and we look forward to welcoming you back soon. Take care and stay safe.

5
Everyone

By on Aug 2, 2022

4
Everyone

By on May 8, 2022

5
Friends

By on Apr 8, 2022

Review comment responded on Apr 8, 2022

Hi Christina, Thank you for staying with us, and thank you also for the score you've given our hotel. This lets us know you've had a wonderful experience as our guest. We thank you again for choosing Sag Harbor Inn for your visit to the Hamptons and we look forward to welcoming you back soon. Take care and stay safe.

5
Everyone

By on Nov 22, 2021

5
Partner Couples

Beautiful building with an extra friendly staff. Wonderful experience!

By , from Pelham on Nov 21, 2021

Review comment responded on Nov 21, 2021

Hi Michael, Thank you not only for staying with us but also for the lovely review of our hotel. Our guests are very important to us. This is why it's our goal to make good on the promise of clean and comfortable rooms; well-kept grounds and public areas; and a friendly face to help make the visit to Sag Harbor and the Hamptons more than worthwhile. This is our brand, and we're very delighted you've had the opportunity to experience it. We thank you again for choosing Sag Harbor Inn and we look forward to welcoming you back soon. Take care and stay safe.

3
Partner Couples

Nice but outdated and nothing special about this hotel. Not having a coffee maker in the room or a microwave stand out among the poor amenities. Pool was "open" but dirty and unheated. And no dining room. Continental breakfast was extremely limited although included in the price of the room, did not justify the amount charged. The balcony was nice and overlooked the harbor. On the plus side, It was quiet and easy walking distance to the town. Staff was pleasant.

By on Oct 4, 2021

Review comment responded on Oct 4, 2021

Hello Sarah, Thank you very much for staying with us, and thank you also for sharing your experience as our guest. We appreciate the feedback we receive because it's an evaluation of our performance. And when we learn our performance is less than perfect, we take a step back to see where we can make improvements. Because we experienced an uptick in our business last year with the pandemic leading guests to travel locally, we closed the beginning of this year to perform repairs so as to keep our hotel fresh. With an even greater turnout this year we plan a similar strategy the beginning of next year when occupancy is at a minimum; this will include performing upgrades to our pool. We make it very clear we have no bar or restaurant on premises, but we always state we are within walking distance to several restaurants offering various cuisines. And while our rooms do not feature a coffee maker or microwave, we offer this amenity 24 hours in our Lobby across from the Front Desk; we also explain this to all our guests on arrival. Our complimentary continental breakfast offers a wide selection, so we do not understand what is meant by, "extremely limited"; nevertheless, we will share your feelings with upper management to see where we can make it right. Again, we thank you for choosing Sag Harbor Inn for your visit to the Hamptons and we also appreciate voicing your opinion of our hotel. We hope to welcome you back as our guest in the future. Take care and stay safe.

5
Everyone

By on Aug 18, 2021

3
Partner Couples

Location and hospitality

By on Aug 5, 2021

Review comment responded on Aug 9, 2021

Dear Guest, Thank you for staying with us, and thank you also for the score you've given our hotel. We hope the experience you've had during your visit to Sag Harbor and the Hamptons has been pleasant, and we look forward to welcoming you back soon.

3
Partner Couples Friends

Na

By on Jul 10, 2021

url importing http://www.orbitz.com/Sag-Harbor-Hotels-Sag-Harbor-Inn.h26497858-p2.Hotel-Reviews
There was an error importing /Sag-Harbor-Hotels-Sag-Harbor-Inn.h26497858-p2.Hotel-Reviews, error: javax.servlet.jsp.JspTagException: 301 http://www.orbitz.com/Sag-Harbor-Hotels-Sag-Harbor-Inn.h26497858-p2.Hotel-Reviews

Frequently asked questions