Skip to main content
Beginning of main content

Salisbury Hotel

3.0 out of 5.0

Recent guest reviews

Paid for wifi but terribly bad signal. No exit fan on toilet. Shower curtain squeezes during shower, very difficult for shower. Hotel location fantastic. Friendly staffs

The location and the staff were outstanding. As soon as we arrived and through until we left, everyone was helpful, and took care of any needs we had such as directions, letting us keep our bags in storage after checkout, and arranging a ride back to the airport. The elevators are incredibly slow and a little rickety, (being on the 16th floor made going up the stairs quite a workout :)) but otherwise the place was just fine for a weekend getaway with my children. Coffee shop, all night grocery store, and Carnegie Hall across the street, minutes away from Central Park and Times Square, and a subway station just up the street, all a bonus. Thank you!!

Furniture, phones and clocks need an update just for aesthetic reasons. I enjoyed my stay.

The location is amazing and most attractions are walking distance. The rooms were clean and the bell-men were very friendly and helpful. The rooms are outdated and the décor looks to be from the 90s, however the rooms are huge. We had a living room, kitchen area, bathroom, and bedroom with 2 huge closets. The only downside to this hotel was that it was outdated and could use some renovation. If you don't mind that, everything else about this hotel was amazing. I would definitely stay again next time I visit NYC.

Hotel location is very convenient walking distance to Times Square ,Central Park , subways. Clean with friendly staff, I didn’t experienced bad odors like other reviews . We had a small inconvenience with the water as they were having some pipes repairs. The staff (manager) were extremely considerable and helpful. Will definitely stay again for my next visit and recommend to family and friends . Not like the 5 star hotel but for price, staff and location it’s worth the stay

Reliable, decent hotel for not too much money, in a terrific location. Clean, professional place, big rooms. Used to be a "fancier" hotel, back in the day, and retains some of that charm. On a block of "fancy hotels." It's dated, so-so maintenance. Really no facilities to speak of -- no bar, restaurant, spa, any of that. But for what you pay them, it's a really, really good bargain. And, the Viceroy across the street (and several others on the block) has your bar & restaurant needs covered. Plus, it's far from Times Square, on the block of Carnegie Hall -- nice neighborhood, centrally located, near the park. There certainly are better hotels but they cost multiples more; there are cheaper hotels, but those would be dumps. This is value.

Beds are very hard. Rooms are very accommodating. Staff was awesome.

The hotel location is great - this is an old world tourist class hotel so it is a little rough around the edges and certainly is not upscale at all, but it is clean and if your on a budget or traveling with a family this will do the trick. I live in the tri-state area so was just spending the night after dinner and drinks and thought I would take a chance - it only cost me $80 so if it wasn't to my liking I would just take the train home, but the room was large and clean, though a bit dated. By large I mean it was a small apartment with a kitchen area, a living room, a bedroom, a bathroom, and 3 walk in closets - that ain't too shabby for $80. Again it was dated, but totally clean.

Booked 2 rooms for a guys weekend trip for a baseball game. The hotel was easy to find and the rooms were as described on the website. One room got a free upgrade and both rooms were clean and comfortable. The staff was easy to deal with and very helpful during our brief stay.

The hotel is in bad shape! Severely dirty! Beds are like bricks! So hard. Linens as minimalistic as possible. Rough dirty stained linens. Deifinitely not a 200.00 to 300.00 room! Location or not. Tape on curling. Exposed wires what use to be door bell . Only 1 Grounded plug and no modern plugs . Smoke alarm not working. No sprinkler in room. Windows too dirty to see out. Ac window unit dropping water all night! Shower filthy. No exhaust fan! In disrepair badly! Spent last night awake as crew with radio on full blast at 1 am had to get people acrossed the hall in room with tile step lippage buckled and locked them out! 1.5 hr later. Terrifying until we figured out what’s going on. Charge for calls!

Older hotel with dated everything but staff were kind and most helpful. Location is fabulous!

Facilities are too old. Can get better rooms with this price.

Needs cleaning. Old dirty towels . The lobby is dirty. And something is biting in the bed

Obviously it is an old building, but it is comfortable and basic, the staff is very friendly. The hotel is located in the heart of Manhattan. It is very difficult to find a hotel in that area with a reasonable price like this. The housekeeper service was excellent! I tried to take one more night, but at the front desk they could not help me, they referred me to the web site for the reservation. I do not know if this is common, but it is not convenient, I have been in Hotels where I can negotiate extra nights in the Front Desk. New building constructions in the area can disturb early in the morning, but this can happen anywhere in Manhattan. It is what it is. I recommend this Hotel for people who are looking for the City Center, with comfort and reasonable prices.

This was a Suite room. The room was cleaned well by housekeeping. However, maintenance of the room was very poor; mismatched tiles in the shower, caulking used a tile grout on the floor, mold in the shower caulking, water damaged vanity with possible mold too, exposed telephone wiring, loose electrical plate, faucet not working. Too few 3 prong outlets (Yes this is an old building but come on 2 prong outlets). The sofa and chairs were soiled and worn.

The location is great, but the hotel is too old, the condition is not good

The hotel location is excellent to tour Manhattan and enjoy Carnegie Hall concert. The NY Central Park is nearby, I can enjoy walking around the park every morning.

Friendly staff in an older but clean hotel. Across the street from Carnegie Hall, Near delis and Central Park. Lots of subway access nearby. We had a great stay.

Great location and price. Room was very large and more than enough closet space. Enjoyed my stay.

The location is good, but this hotel is run down, outdated, and dumpy. I would not recommend it to anyone.

123 W 57th St New York NY

Hotel highlights

  • Walking distance to Central Park and Carnegie Hall
  • WiFi in rooms and public areas (fees apply)
  • Business center
  • Concierge services

Located in Midtown, Salisbury Hotel is adjacent to Carnegie Hall and within a 5-minute walk of other popular sights like Central Park. This 196-room, 3-star hotel welcomes guests with conveniences like a business center, concierge services, and express check-in. Centrally located in New York, the hotel is also a short walk from Rockefeller Center and Barney's.


Dining

Savor a meal from the comfort of your room with room service.


Rooms

Guests can expect to find WiFi and 32-inch a flat-screen TV with cable channels. The bathroom offers hair dryers and designer toiletries. Other standard amenities include a microwave, a safe, and an ironing board.


Property features

Guests of Salisbury Hotel enjoy WiFi in public areas, a business center, and express check-in. Self parking is available for USD 24 per night. The 24-hour front desk has multilingual staff ready to assist with luggage storage, concierge services, and securing valuables. Additional amenities include express check-out and a porter/bellhop.

Room options

Suite, 1 King Bed

King 1 | Sleeps 2

Suite, 2 Double Beds

Full 2 | Sleeps 4

Standard rooms Two Double Beds/No Pantry

Full 2 | Sleeps 4

Standard Room, 2 Double Beds

Full 2 | Sleeps 4

Guest reviews for Salisbury Hotel

Everyone (126) Couples (1) Students (1) Family (3) Other (1)
3
Everyone

Paid for wifi but terribly bad signal. No exit fan on toilet. Shower curtain squeezes during shower, very difficult for shower. Hotel location fantastic. Friendly staffs

By on Jul 18, 2018

5
Everyone

The location and the staff were outstanding. As soon as we arrived and through until we left, everyone was helpful, and took care of any needs we had such as directions, letting us keep our bags in storage after checkout, and arranging a ride back to the airport. The elevators are incredibly slow and a little rickety, (being on the 16th floor made going up the stairs quite a workout :)) but otherwise the place was just fine for a weekend getaway with my children. Coffee shop, all night grocery store, and Carnegie Hall across the street, minutes away from Central Park and Times Square, and a subway station just up the street, all a bonus. Thank you!!

By , from Maine on Jul 17, 2018

5

great location!

Everyone

Furniture, phones and clocks need an update just for aesthetic reasons. I enjoyed my stay.

By on Jul 12, 2018

5
Everyone

The location is amazing and most attractions are walking distance. The rooms were clean and the bell-men were very friendly and helpful. The rooms are outdated and the décor looks to be from the 90s, however the rooms are huge. We had a living room, kitchen area, bathroom, and bedroom with 2 huge closets. The only downside to this hotel was that it was outdated and could use some renovation. If you don't mind that, everything else about this hotel was amazing. I would definitely stay again next time I visit NYC.

By , from MI on Jul 11, 2018

5
Everyone

Hotel location is very convenient walking distance to Times Square ,Central Park , subways. Clean with friendly staff, I didn’t experienced bad odors like other reviews . We had a small inconvenience with the water as they were having some pipes repairs. The staff (manager) were extremely considerable and helpful. Will definitely stay again for my next visit and recommend to family and friends . Not like the 5 star hotel but for price, staff and location it’s worth the stay

By , from Cape Coral FL on Jul 9, 2018

3

terrific value, reliable, great location

Everyone

Reliable, decent hotel for not too much money, in a terrific location. Clean, professional place, big rooms. Used to be a "fancier" hotel, back in the day, and retains some of that charm. On a block of "fancy hotels." It's dated, so-so maintenance. Really no facilities to speak of -- no bar, restaurant, spa, any of that. But for what you pay them, it's a really, really good bargain. And, the Viceroy across the street (and several others on the block) has your bar & restaurant needs covered. Plus, it's far from Times Square, on the block of Carnegie Hall -- nice neighborhood, centrally located, near the park. There certainly are better hotels but they cost multiples more; there are cheaper hotels, but those would be dumps. This is value.

By on Jul 5, 2018

5

nice hotel

Everyone

Beds are very hard. Rooms are very accommodating. Staff was awesome.

By on Jul 3, 2018

3

location, location, location

Everyone

The hotel location is great - this is an old world tourist class hotel so it is a little rough around the edges and certainly is not upscale at all, but it is clean and if your on a budget or traveling with a family this will do the trick. I live in the tri-state area so was just spending the night after dinner and drinks and thought I would take a chance - it only cost me $80 so if it wasn't to my liking I would just take the train home, but the room was large and clean, though a bit dated. By large I mean it was a small apartment with a kitchen area, a living room, a bedroom, a bathroom, and 3 walk in closets - that ain't too shabby for $80. Again it was dated, but totally clean.

By , from Connecticut on Jul 2, 2018

4
Everyone

Booked 2 rooms for a guys weekend trip for a baseball game. The hotel was easy to find and the rooms were as described on the website. One room got a free upgrade and both rooms were clean and comfortable. The staff was easy to deal with and very helpful during our brief stay.

By on Jul 2, 2018

1
Everyone

The hotel is in bad shape! Severely dirty! Beds are like bricks! So hard. Linens as minimalistic as possible. Rough dirty stained linens. Deifinitely not a 200.00 to 300.00 room! Location or not. Tape on curling. Exposed wires what use to be door bell . Only 1 Grounded plug and no modern plugs . Smoke alarm not working. No sprinkler in room. Windows too dirty to see out. Ac window unit dropping water all night! Shower filthy. No exhaust fan! In disrepair badly! Spent last night awake as crew with radio on full blast at 1 am had to get people acrossed the hall in room with tile step lippage buckled and locked them out! 1.5 hr later. Terrifying until we figured out what’s going on. Charge for calls!

By , from reno on Jul 1, 2018