Skip to main content
Beginning of main content

Club Comanche Hotel, St. Croix

3.0 out of 5.0

Recent guest reviews

We lived on St Croix for many years and came back for several weeks and chose a downtown hotel because of the ease of trying all the new restaurants. We had an awesome time.

Like: the charm and quaintness of the place. Dislike: the lack of "wall installation" to prevent loud disturbing noises from impacting neighboring rooms.Also need for mold remediation of old section of hotel.

Charming but under repairs. Noisy and unreliable hot water.

As we walked to the building from the cab, we did not think the building was livable. There was siding missing and windows boarded up. The entrance looked like an abandoned building with the office on the second floor. The room was large, closet space was 2 cupboard that were dusty, the bathroom was clean and OK thank god the AC worked!! We had a mosquito problem " in the room," always getting bite, when I told the Hotel manager he said "Tis the season" When it rained, often the water would run in from the window onto the floor. The morning breakfast which you had to pay for along with wifi when you arrived was OK, it had the basics for a quick light breakfast. We saw one couple that refused to stay at the hotel, most people were understanding since there had been a hurricane but this hotel was not ready for guests - certainly not without and up front disclosure on the condition and the price should have reflected the condition. Orbitz should do a better job when recommending Hotel, will not rely on them in the future!

Nightlife, day time activities, shopping. In the center of it all. Old/ rustic building that gives the feel of danish history and wishing if only the walls could talk. The staff were very nice, friendly, hospitable and courteous. I was even allowed a late checkout due to my late flight departure. The room was clean and the bed was comfortable. A/C is cold. Wifi pretty decent. The tv only had 2 channels with clear picture and clear sound. You must take your repellent because the mosquitos in the room are pesky. The pool is closed for repairs. I didn't eat in the Hoyle restaurant but I here it's pretty good.

My air condition was damage and no one came to fix the problem. The breakfast was poor

I stayed at this hotel from 11/25-28/2016. The hotel is in the perfect location, in the heart of Christiansted town and is surrounded by dining, water and other hotels whose facilities and service, I am sure would be better than what I received while at Comanche. Long story short (or this would seem like a rant lol), the room was tiny, the bed was a death trap (uncomfortable, noisy and unstable), forget about watching tv anywhere else but standing in front of it (due to the height of the screen and no way to angle it). Reporting issues to the front desk was a waste because they were never resolved. As much as I enjoyed St Croix, my next visit will definitely NOT be at Comanche.

Hotel in need of a massive infusion of cash to bring it up to Fair. Elevator has been dismantled for years. Several guest rooms are being renovated, probably out of service for years. WiFi spotty at best. Bar just reopened after being closed for Six Years. Breakfast was good, not elaborate but decent. A nearby outside band played until midnight, way too loud! The hotel is convenient to shopping and restaurants. Bombay Club was a gem of a quaint bar and restaurant. Board walk along the harbor has some good eating spots with nice views.

Our plane was 2 hours late for arrival in St. Croix. "Carmen" kept the light on for us - (literally) and greeted us at the door with a chilled bottle of champaigne. The services we received were outstanding. All the staff were kind and attentive to assist us in any way they could - even helping us to track down our lost luggage. The location was very close to the boardwalk - no car needed - taxi service was just a step away. The room was very clean. I would recommend Club Comanche to anyone going to St. Croix. The only change to the "Run of the House" would be adding a microwave to the room.

Great place, near board walk and in center of the town and stores

Great Centric location Near the board walk and many pubs with nightlife In the center of the town Pool was damage and water green!! That the only thing, they have problems with the contractor... but hey the beach is so near!!

Very nice accomadtions and personel very friendly. Great location to dining, stores and beaches

In spite of every efforts made to renovate the rooms, this hotel remains an rickety colonial building in the heart of the boardwalk area peppered with bars. Great if you're in a party mood, but not if you need to sleep. Not to mention the roosters outside your window who will make sure you wake up at 5AM.

I stayed with my girlfriend in the jr suit with a king size bed. It was awesome. No it is not a brand new building like i am used to in minneapolis mn but it was had gorgeous dark wood floor that maids mop everyday to keep clean. they dont change your sheets everyday like a hilton but they save energy and water by skipping a day. yes they dont change them between people. the staff are very friendly and there is a guy named [...] and he is 10 times more of a help and nicer then any hilton or ramada employee ive ever talked to. the hotel is located a block down from the ocean and center of the shopping and resturants. it is great location and great experience. i will be going back.

Unhelpful desk clerk at check in, and the room was difficult to get to with luggage (several sets of stairs and no one there to help). Newly remodeled room but already getting shabby (by not cleaning in the corners, not repairing furniture, etc.). We thought there was sand in the bed--turned out to be a termite problem. The pool couldn't be used because it leaked. The NOISE was awful--a party until after 3 in the hotel bar just outside our window on Saturday, with no warning except when the hotel clerk woke us up to give us free tickets to the event later that night. Complained to the front desk (repeatedly) but they simply said, "We left a message for the manager."

This location lets you explore the historic fort dating from the 1750's. The boardwalk shouldn't be missed.

No 1 Strand Street Christiansted St. Croix

Hotel highlights

  • Walking distance to Fort Christiansvaern
  • Free breakfast
  • Free WiFi in rooms and public areas
  • Onsite dining

Club Comanche Hotel, St. Croix places you next to Leeward Islands and St. Croix Government House. This 20-room, 3-star hotel has conveniences like free breakfast, a restaurant, and free in-room WiFi.


Dining

Free breakfast is offered each morning from 7:00 AM to 9:00 AM. Enjoy a bite to eat at the hotel's restaurant, or relax with a drink at the bar/lounge.


Rooms

A flat-screen TV comes with satellite channels, and guests can stay connected with free WiFi. Pillowtop beds sport premium bedding and down comforters, and the bathroom offers a rainfall showerhead, a hair dryer, and free toiletries. Other standard amenities include a coffee maker, free local calls, and a ceiling fan.


Property features

Club Comanche Hotel, St. Croix features free WiFi in public areas, a meeting room, and a terrace. If you drive, take advantage of free offsite parking. Staff members can answer questions about accommodations, and also provide front-desk service during limited hours. This smoke-free hotel also has a garden.

Room options

Premium Suite

King 1 | Sleeps 2

Superior Suite

Full 2 | Sleeps 4

Classic Suite

Queen 1 | Sleeps 2

Guest reviews for Club Comanche Hotel, St. Croix

Everyone (7) Couples (4) Business (3) Family (1) Other (1) Friends (1)
4
Partner Couples Families

We lived on St Croix for many years and came back for several weeks and chose a downtown hotel because of the ease of trying all the new restaurants. We had an awesome time.

By , from Melbourne Florida on Jun 6, 2019

1
Everyone

By on Mar 25, 2019

3
Business Business Travelers

Like: the charm and quaintness of the place. Dislike: the lack of "wall installation" to prevent loud disturbing noises from impacting neighboring rooms.Also need for mold remediation of old section of hotel.

By on Mar 25, 2019

3
Everyone

Charming but under repairs. Noisy and unreliable hot water.

By on Nov 4, 2018

2

needs more time to repair from hurricane

Everyone

As we walked to the building from the cab, we did not think the building was livable. There was siding missing and windows boarded up. The entrance looked like an abandoned building with the office on the second floor. The room was large, closet space was 2 cupboard that were dusty, the bathroom was clean and OK thank god the AC worked!! We had a mosquito problem " in the room," always getting bite, when I told the Hotel manager he said "Tis the season" When it rained, often the water would run in from the window onto the floor. The morning breakfast which you had to pay for along with wifi when you arrived was OK, it had the basics for a quick light breakfast. We saw one couple that refused to stay at the hotel, most people were understanding since there had been a hurricane but this hotel was not ready for guests - certainly not without and up front disclosure on the condition and the price should have reflected the condition. Orbitz should do a better job when recommending Hotel, will not rely on them in the future!

By on Feb 15, 2018

4

nostalgic

Everyone

Nightlife, day time activities, shopping. In the center of it all. Old/ rustic building that gives the feel of danish history and wishing if only the walls could talk. The staff were very nice, friendly, hospitable and courteous. I was even allowed a late checkout due to my late flight departure. The room was clean and the bed was comfortable. A/C is cold. Wifi pretty decent. The tv only had 2 channels with clear picture and clear sound. You must take your repellent because the mosquitos in the room are pesky. The pool is closed for repairs. I didn't eat in the Hoyle restaurant but I here it's pretty good.

By , from woodbridge, va on Aug 29, 2017

Review comment responded on Sep 8, 2017

Thank you for your review and stay with us. We look forward to you coming back!!!

3

poor service

Everyone

My air condition was damage and no one came to fix the problem. The breakfast was poor

By on Apr 17, 2017

1

i will not be returning to this hotel

Everyone

I stayed at this hotel from 11/25-28/2016. The hotel is in the perfect location, in the heart of Christiansted town and is surrounded by dining, water and other hotels whose facilities and service, I am sure would be better than what I received while at Comanche. Long story short (or this would seem like a rant lol), the room was tiny, the bed was a death trap (uncomfortable, noisy and unstable), forget about watching tv anywhere else but standing in front of it (due to the height of the screen and no way to angle it). Reporting issues to the front desk was a waste because they were never resolved. As much as I enjoyed St Croix, my next visit will definitely NOT be at Comanche.

By , from Orlando, FL on Nov 29, 2016

1

never again!

Everyone

Hotel in need of a massive infusion of cash to bring it up to Fair. Elevator has been dismantled for years. Several guest rooms are being renovated, probably out of service for years. WiFi spotty at best. Bar just reopened after being closed for Six Years. Breakfast was good, not elaborate but decent. A nearby outside band played until midnight, way too loud! The hotel is convenient to shopping and restaurants. Bombay Club was a gem of a quaint bar and restaurant. Board walk along the harbor has some good eating spots with nice views.

By , from Chicago on Nov 20, 2016

5

40th anniversary celebratiion

Couples

Our plane was 2 hours late for arrival in St. Croix. "Carmen" kept the light on for us - (literally) and greeted us at the door with a chilled bottle of champaigne. The services we received were outstanding. All the staff were kind and attentive to assist us in any way they could - even helping us to track down our lost luggage. The location was very close to the boardwalk - no car needed - taxi service was just a step away. The room was very clean. I would recommend Club Comanche to anyone going to St. Croix. The only change to the "Run of the House" would be adding a microwave to the room.

By on Jul 28, 2013