This was our first trip to SSI. We LOVED it! The island is very private and not overrun with tourists/franchise chains. Located on East Beach, this is prime real estate for SSI beaches. Walking/biking distance to Pier Village. The island has plenty of safe bike paths. The beach at low tide is apx. 300 yards from boardwalk to water; 200 yards at high tide. Pools are adequate but could have been more enjoyable if they were bigger in size due to the number of guests using them (I'm being knit-picky here).
The home is very nice and equipped with good amenities. The ice maker is a bonus and helps keep the coolers full. Furniture is the only negative. The quality/comfort is average, but, hey, it's a rental. I get it. Plenty of dishes/pots/pans/utensils/appliances/towels. But if you like to cook, bring your good pans/knives ;)
The location of the home with respect to the pool pavilion is an easy walk. If comparing other Coast Cottage homes, consider the parking arrangements. Some of the homes only offer parallel parking, which can be tricky for some, especially with large SUV's. Oleander home has head-in parking which is great.
We found the area very easy to get around. Plenty of options with regards to restaurants, grocery, shops, pharmacies etc. Nearly all of the restaurants are locally owned/operated. While they're smaller in size, they make up for it in quality and value of the meal. We never had a bad meal.
The property manager was great to work with! He was easily accessible, responded to emails, gave good recommendations of the area and greeted us shortly after arrival to ensure a successful stay.
Overall, this was a great place and SSI is a wonderful area. We will definitely consider Coast Cottages when we book next time.