Compare Shelter Island Cabin Rentals

Cabins in Shelter Island cost from just $89 a night to $425 a night for that something truly special. Prices and availability are subject to change. Additional terms may apply.

You might fancy a luxury log cabin retreat for a romantic getaway. Maybe you’re after a family lodge in the woods or a rustic hideaway by the water. With a fantastic selection of 3 unique Shelter Island cabins to choose from, your perfect escape is just a click away.

To see the latest deals on Shelter Island cabins rentals, enter your travel details and hit search. Arrange your results by price to see the cheapest options first and use the budget filter, map, and ratings to compare cabins. We find prices are often lower during , so this could be the best time to find a cabin bargain.

Picture a cozy space full of personality, space, and privacy. A cabin booked through Orbitz is a place where you can escape the rat race, unwind, and make plans on your private deck, cocooned by trees, water, or views for days. Cook for yourself, just as you like it, share special moments, and build memories.

Sink into your outdoor hot tub in a secluded cabin rental or let the kids splash around in a cabin resort’s indoor pool. Our amenities filters make it easy to find cabins in Shelter Island that deliver those special extras that make all the difference.

Click on our pet-friendly filter for woof-tastic Shelter Island cabins rentals, where your pooch can enjoy a vacation, too. Take walks to dog-happy cafés, explore nature together from sunrise to sundown, then snuggle together in front of a cozy log fire or under the twinkling stars on your deck.

To find those luxury cabins with the top-notch touches you’re looking for, use the budget filter, read customer reviews, and dip into the property listings for the details. You can then compare cabins and choose the best cabins for a truly luxurious experience.

Enter your travel details, hit search, and use the filters to see our best deals on cabins in Shelter Island. Easy! From luxury log cabin rentals to affordable weekend cabin getaways, Orbitz finds your dream cabin in just a few clicks. You can unlock Orbucks when you sign up for Orbitz RewardsOpens in a new window, too.