Cheap flights To Shelter Island (LGA) from $25

Earn rewards on top of your airline miles with Orbitz Rewards

Many airlines offer flexible change policies

Sign up to receive text alerts about your trip

Cheap Flights to Shelter Island from $25 One Way, $49 Round Trip

Prices found within past 7 days. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.

Thu, Nov 13 - Mon, Nov 17
ATL
Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta Intl.
EWR
Newark Liberty Intl. Airport
$49 Roundtrip, just found
$49
Roundtrip
just found
Select Spirit Airlines flight, departing Thu, Nov 13 from Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta Intl. to Newark Liberty Intl. Airport, returning Mon, Nov 17, priced at $49 just found
Thu, Nov 13 - Tue, Nov 18
ATL
Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta Intl.
EWR
Newark Liberty Intl. Airport
$55 Roundtrip, found 1 hour ago
$55
Roundtrip
found 1 hour ago
Select Spirit Airlines flight, departing Thu, Nov 13 from Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta Intl. to Newark Liberty Intl. Airport, returning Tue, Nov 18, priced at $55 found 1 hour ago
Wed, Nov 12 - Tue, Nov 18
ATL
Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta Intl.
EWR
Newark Liberty Intl. Airport
$56 Roundtrip, found 4 hours ago
$56
Roundtrip
found 4 hours ago
Select Spirit Airlines flight, departing Wed, Nov 12 from Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta Intl. to Newark Liberty Intl. Airport, returning Tue, Nov 18, priced at $56 found 4 hours ago
Sat, Nov 15 - Mon, Nov 17
ATL
Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta Intl.
EWR
Newark Liberty Intl. Airport
$59 Roundtrip, just found
$59
Roundtrip
just found
Select Frontier Airlines flight, departing Sat, Nov 15 from Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta Intl. to Newark Liberty Intl. Airport, returning Mon, Nov 17, priced at $59 just found
Tue, Nov 18 - Thu, Nov 20
ATL
Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta Intl.
EWR
Newark Liberty Intl. Airport
$60 Roundtrip, just found
$60
Roundtrip
just found
Select Spirit Airlines flight, departing Tue, Nov 18 from Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta Intl. to Newark Liberty Intl. Airport, returning Thu, Nov 20, priced at $60 just found
Wed, Nov 12 - Mon, Nov 17
ATL
Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta Intl.
EWR
Newark Liberty Intl. Airport
$62 Roundtrip, found 1 hour ago
$62
Roundtrip
found 1 hour ago
Select Spirit Airlines flight, departing Wed, Nov 12 from Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta Intl. to Newark Liberty Intl. Airport, returning Mon, Nov 17, priced at $62 found 1 hour ago
Tue, Nov 11 - Tue, Nov 18
ATL
Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta Intl.
EWR
Newark Liberty Intl. Airport
$63 Roundtrip, found 4 hours ago
$63
Roundtrip
found 4 hours ago
Select Spirit Airlines flight, departing Tue, Nov 11 from Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta Intl. to Newark Liberty Intl. Airport, returning Tue, Nov 18, priced at $63 found 4 hours ago
Thu, Nov 13 - Thu, Nov 13
ATL
Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta Intl.
LGA
LaGuardia
$63 Roundtrip, found 1 hour ago
$63
Roundtrip
found 1 hour ago
Select Frontier Airlines flight, departing Thu, Nov 13 from Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta Intl. to LaGuardia, returning Thu, Nov 13, priced at $63 found 1 hour ago
Sat, Jan 31 - Sat, Jan 31
ATL
Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta Intl.
JFK
John F. Kennedy Intl.
$63 Roundtrip, just found
$63
Roundtrip
just found
Select Frontier Airlines flight, departing Sat, Jan 31 from Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta Intl. to John F. Kennedy Intl., returning Sat, Jan 31, priced at $63 just found
Wed, Nov 12 - Wed, Nov 12
ATL
Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta Intl.
LGA
LaGuardia
$63 Roundtrip, found 1 day ago
$63
Roundtrip
found 1 day ago
Select Frontier Airlines flight, departing Wed, Nov 12 from Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta Intl. to LaGuardia, returning Wed, Nov 12, priced at $63 found 1 day ago

Shelter Island Flight Information

Traveling To
Shelter Island
Destination Airport IATA Code
LGA
Number of Airlines Serving
Airlines
Spirit Airlines, Frontier Airlines
Flight Price
$49
Earliest Departing Flight
Latest Departing Flight

Book Your Flight & Hotel Together & Save

Shelter Island economy flight packages

Price found within the past 48 hours. Click for updated prices.
Night Hotel Broadway
2.5-star property

Night Hotel Broadway

Dec 8 - Dec 11

3 night stay

Atlanta (ATL) to New York (JFK)

Frontier Airlines • Roundtrip • Coach
Save 100% on your flight
Price was $970, price is now $557 per person
$557
per person
found 1 day ago
Courtyard New York Manhattan/ Midtown East
3.0-star property

Courtyard New York Manhattan/ Midtown East

Dec 4 - Dec 7

3 night stay

Atlanta (ATL) to New York (JFK)

Frontier Airlines • Roundtrip • Coach
Price was $2,604, price is now $1,430 per person
$1,430
per person
found 1 day ago
Global Luxury Suites at The Arches
2.5-star property

Global Luxury Suites at The Arches

Dec 24 - Dec 27

3 night stay

Orlando (MCO) to New York (JFK)

Spirit Airlines • Roundtrip • Coach
Save 100% on your flight
Price was $1,192, price is now $738 per person
$738
per person
found 1 day ago
Don't see what you're looking for?
See all available trips from Atlanta to Shelter Island
View all trips

Shelter Island premium economy flight packages

Price found within the past 48 hours. Click for updated prices.
The Inn At Fox Hollow Hotel
4.0-star property

The Inn At Fox Hollow Hotel

9.2/10 Wonderful! (1,002 reviews)

Dec 4 - Dec 7

3 night stay

Atlanta (ATL) to New York (JFK)

Delta • Roundtrip • PremiumEconomy
Save 100% on your flight
Price was $1,192, price is now $738 per person
$738
per person
found 24 hours ago
Very nice and clean large rooms

Reviewed on Jan 21, 2025

Pendry Natirar
5.0-star property

Pendry Natirar

9.8/10 Exceptional! (7 reviews)

Dec 4 - Dec 7

3 night stay

Atlanta (ATL) to New York (NYC)

Delta • Roundtrip • PremiumEconomy
Save 100% on your flight
Price was $2,292, price is now $1,525 per person
$1,525
per person
found 24 hours ago
The George
4.0-star property

The George

9.4/10 Exceptional! (437 reviews)

Dec 4 - Dec 7

3 night stay

Atlanta (ATL) to Newark Liberty Intl. Airport (EWR)

Delta • Roundtrip • PremiumEconomy
Price was $1,034, price is now $757 per person
$757
per person
found 24 hours ago
Beautiful little hotel. Highly recommended.

Reviewed on Aug 25, 2025

Don't see what you're looking for?
See all available trips from Atlanta to Shelter Island
View all trips

Shelter Island first class flight packages

Price found within the past 48 hours. Click for updated prices.
PUBLIC, an Ian Schrager hotel
4.0-star property

PUBLIC, an Ian Schrager hotel

8.4/10 Very Good! (3,064 reviews)

Dec 7 - Dec 10

3 night stay

Atlanta (ATL) to New York (JFK)

American Airlines • Roundtrip • FirstClass
Price was $1,482, price is now $1,131 per person
$1,131
per person
found 1 day ago
Nice though small, had mechanical problems w drapes. Staff are great hotel beautifully decorated. There is a club on site so definitely loud at night on the street below. Lots of marijuana smoke, and had to call about the neighbors smoking a couple times because it was super skunky and totally invaded my room.

Reviewed on Jun 15, 2025

Hotel Riu Plaza New York Times Square
4.0-star property

Hotel Riu Plaza New York Times Square

9/10 Wonderful! (2,748 reviews)

Dec 7 - Dec 10

3 night stay

Atlanta (ATL) to New York (JFK)

American Airlines • Roundtrip • FirstClass
Save 100% on your flight
Price was $2,066, price is now $1,345 per person
$1,345
per person
found 1 day ago
V gd in all respects

Reviewed on Sep 28, 2025

1 Hotel Central Park
5.0-star property

1 Hotel Central Park

9/10 Wonderful! (1,008 reviews)

Dec 7 - Dec 10

3 night stay

Atlanta (ATL) to New York (JFK)

American Airlines • Roundtrip • FirstClass
Save 100% on your flight
Price was $3,341, price is now $2,357 per person
$2,357
per person
found 1 day ago
We have traditionally always stayed in the theater district area however more recently the area has changed. More homeless, dirtier and just not as enjoyable for us. We decided to stay more uptown in the central park area and the Orbitz site recommended the 1 Hotel Central Park. From the moment we checked in it was truly like a zen feeling and experience. Less hustle and bustle checking in, the staff was super friendly, attentive and helpful in every way from the check to the concierge. The room was modern (in a zen way), mini bar was stocked with wines, drinks and snacks. A coffee pod machine as well. The restaurant Jams, was excellent for breakfast and always packed! We HIGHLY recommend staying here and as a matter of fact tyhis will be our new go to staying in NYC.

Reviewed on Jul 13, 2025

Don't see what you're looking for?
See all available trips from Atlanta to Shelter Island
View all trips

Shelter Island

Save money on your flights to Shelter Island as well as on hotel and car packages.

 

Free Fees

Snap up cheap Shelter Island flights at Orbitz, and pay no booking fees. We also don’t charge fees when your plans change or are cancelled. While you’re there, check out our low fare deals on flights to other locations besides flights to Shelter Island.

Everyday Is a Great Day to Save Even More

Get bonus points from Orbitz, the best discount travel planner in the business. Use your Orbitz Visa to take advantage of sales on Shelter Island flights, or pile on points by using it for gas, groceries, and other everyday goods and services. Pack your wallet with even more savings using our cutting-edge suite of mobile tools.

Mix and Match

At Orbitz, we turned a great idea from the world of fashion into another way for you to save money. When you shop our low cost tickets on flights to any destination, don’t be afraid to mix and match different airlines for maximum savings on your Shelter Island flights air ticket. Save more on air travel every day in every way at Orbitz.

Frequently asked questions

How much is a flight to Shelter Island?
Travelers from near and far landed return-flight bargains ranging between $49 and $63 this week. Arriving from Atlanta (ATL)? The best one-way prices were just $25.
How to book the cheapest flight to Shelter Island?
Picking up cheap flights to Shelter Island is as easy as booking with Orbitz. But if you'd like to make sure you're walking away with the best flight deals around, here are some suggestions your wallet will love:

  • Consider departing from or arriving at alternative airports to save on your flight. Enter your preferred departure and arrival airports in the form fields, then click on the 'Nearby airports' function below. It will show you any available options.
  • If you're flexible with your travel schedule, click on the 'Show flexible dates' link. It'll display the flight deals for the days before and after your selected departure. Ticket prices often vary depending on what day of the week it is.
  • You can also hit the 'Show options' link to filter results for your preferred carrier, seating class, and nonstop and refundable flights. Under 'Sort & Filter' to the left, you can even pick the time of day you want to fly.
  • Once you've figured out your travel dates, don't delay booking your flight. Prices normally rise as the departure date gets closer.
  • Make even more savings on your trip by combining your hotel, flights and car rentals into a package. Your budget will thank you for it.
  • Flying during the busy season can mean pricey airfares. If possible, plan your vacation outside of popular dates, such as Thanksgiving, New Year's Eve and Easter.

What is the best time to book a flight to Shelter Island?
Book in January, February or August for the lowest airfares to Shelter Island. Once you've found a bargain, buy it — cheap flights tend to pop up and then vanish in the click of a mouse.
What day of the week is the cheapest to book a flight to Shelter Island?
Make a booking on a Tuesday, Wednesday or Saturday. Generally, these are the cheapest days to purchase fares to Shelter Island. The vacation of your dreams starts with a fantastic flight deal!
What is the cheapest day of the week to fly to Shelter Island?
According to Orbitz data from 2020, you should jump on a plane on a Monday to score cheap flights to Shelter Island. Next cheapest day? Tuesday. Saturday is the most expensive. So, leave early in the week if you'd like to book a wallet-friendly fare without paying premium prices.
What is the cheapest month to fly to Shelter Island?
To land cheap flights to Shelter Island, you should depart in August. If getting a great deal on your plane ticket is your top priority, Orbitz data has found that this is generally an excellent month to travel. June is when fares are at their highest.
Which airlines allow free cancellation?
We understand that plans change and flexibility is more important than ever. That's why you can search for flights that have free cancellation and no change fees on Orbitz. Just click on "Filter by flexible change policies" and we'll show you fares with more flexibility than a lip balm left in the sun!
What do I need for the flight to Shelter Island?
Whether you're a regular flyer or it's your first time on a plane, it helps to be organized when you travel. Here are a few tips and things to take into account:

  • Firstly, you'll need to take all applicable travel documents and your identification. How much is dependent on where you're flying from. When you book, always use the correct name, birth date and gender listed on your government-issued ID.
  • Fill your carry-on bag with snacks and things to keep you busy and you'll easily pass the time on this medium-haul flight. If possible, hop on the airport's Wi-Fi and transfer your favorite podcast or playlist to your device before take off.
  • Never mind what the season is at your destination, aircraft cabins can feel quite cool. Carry a sweater on your journey to stay warm and comfy.

How do I get cheap first-class/business deals to Shelter Island?
Experienced travelers know how to find business or first-class fares to Shelter Island without the sky-high price tag. Be like them with these handy tips:

  • Being flexible isn't just a yoga thing. Avoid locking in your travel dates so you can snap up more affordable airfares when a big sale comes along.
  • Look for a low-cost airline that has business-class seats. They usually come with extra space and a glass of Champagne — and a nicer price.
  • Make a bid for an upgrade. Some carriers hold online auctions that let you put down a price for a seat up the front. You may also be able to upgrade with points earned through a loyalty scheme.

More to Explore

Fare, taxes & fees: Fares include all taxes and fees, except baggage fees. Rates shown reflect fares found by other Orbitz users over the past 7 days. Due to rapidly changing airline prices & seat availability, these fares may no longer be available.

Refunds/changes/cancellations: Itinerary changes, if permitted for the fare, will have a $30 service fee charged by Orbitz. Additional airline charges may apply.

Other conditions: Schedules, fares and rules are subject to change without notice. Seats are limited and may not be available on all flights/dates or in all markets. Lower fares may be available. Fares will not be honored retroactively or in exchange for any wholly/partially unused ticket. Tickets are non-transferable and non-refundable. Fare rules are provided for the selected itinerary before booking.