We stayed in cabin #2, small but sufficient. Great getaway near Helen. Good Wi-Fi, but TV options not great. Hot tub was good. Bare minimum supplies - only 1 extra pillow, no extra blankets (and beds only have 1 blanket each). No dishwasher in kitchen, and very small kitchen. Bathrooms are very small, sufficient for us, but toilet in guest was way too small. We ordered the firewood for the fire pit and asked about paper or fire starter (none provided, so we brought our own), but no matches or lighter! (by the way - they sell firewood just down the way toward Helen). Only one side of the gas grill worked. The only shower is in the master bedroom and no door or curtain on the shower area, so the entire room has to be empty for someone to shower. Closet space is great. There is an apartment-sized washer/dryer - bring your own laundry detergent. I only saw 1 horseshoe for that game, almost all the darts for the dartboard were broken, no chalk for the pool sticks, pool table was in poor condition.
I did not try to call the property manager for anything because my phone was having some troubles.
Overall, the reason this wins over cabins is the hot tub!