Overall, we really enjoyed our stay here. There are a lot of good things about this place. The view is incredible, the place was very clean when we arrived, the city is not nearly as crowded as the nearby towns of Positano and Amalfi, and the property manager helped us coordinate with restaurants and other activities to help make our stay very nice.
On the other hand, our biggest disappointment of our stay happened to occur during check in. We were coming from Tuscany and by the time we got to Praiano it was just after 6pm, we were informed by the property manager that we had to pay an additional 50 euros for "late check in." We tried explaining that we never were made aware of a late check in fee (although 6pm is hardly a late check in), but he said we should have known and it was on the contract. I showed him what I had and it said nothing of a late check in fee, so he said I should take a picture of the form he had on hand. Eventually the property manager said he was just following orders from the owner and he had no control over it. It was very disappointing for us because we were not made aware of a late fee, were not told through any communication that we would be charged a late fee, and it got our stay off to a bad start. There were other taxes and fees that the property manager collected on site which we came to expect (Italians really nickel and dime tourists!), but these were normal. The beds were really hard and the trash situation could have been made better.