Skip to main content
Beginning of main content

Recent guest reviews

Staff was amazing!

Amusing. Everything very clean. The people very nice.

Terrible check in time. Arrived early was told I would be on the early check in list. Did not get to check in till well after 4pm. To add to the insult, the next day kept getting harassed to be out by 11am.

I’ve stayed in many places on the Vineyard over the years, but this has got to be the very best! I arrived early due to my flight and the staff let me check in early. The room was perfect! The beds were comparable to diamon-level accommodations I’ve enjoyed on the past. The locale was perfect as I did not need to drive anywhere being that this was in the center of everything beautiful that Martha’s Vineyard has to offer. The best quality about this hotel: the staff. They are genuine, welcoming, and professional. I look forward to staying here again.

Location and style was perfect for MV. Affordable and restaurant was good too.

Great location, with pool and bar. Walking distance to great shops and restaurants.

This was our second year staying at Kelley House with our 2 sons and one of their girlfriends(in their 20's)-it's a beautiful hotel, old and charming, but modern and stylish inside(think Serena and Lily). The location is ideal-walking distance to the Falmouth ferry, movie theater, Lighthouse Beach, and all shops and restaurants in Edgartown. The rooms are spacious and nicely decorated, and always had plenty of towels, bathroom items etc. Nice added touch are the muffins/coffee in the am and cookies/tea in the evening. The staff here is always wonderful and helpful...highly recommend! One tip:For guests renting bikes from the shop down the road, it would be great if the hotel rack could be relocated someplace that doesn't get flooded from the rain and if the hotel would cover those bikes with tarps at night as well. We'd be happy to rent them from the hotel if they provided bikes with more speeds for really cruising around the island.

Very nice! Close to everything. Convenient parking.

Pretty old historic hotel. Great staff and location

The room I stayed in had a HORRIBLE musty odor & the furniture seemed moist. I kept my clothes packed because I didn't want the smell to get in them. The pillows were nice, but the bed was somewhat uncomfortable. I also really didn't enjoy having to park at least a block away from the hotel & then walk back by myself at night.

Perfect location to shops and restaurants. We did not need transportation to get to any of the places we were interested in going to. Since the location was central, we could easily return to the hotel and enjoy people watching and rest from the lovely outside seating....Highly recommend.

Great hotel. Stayed for two nights. Nice location. Close to every thing!

It’s was great and no complaints. The staff was great and they helped up when it comes to things to do on the island along with restaurants. It was also at a great location.

Great experience! wonderful location, beautiful room!

Located in the town square. Lots of places to eat, all very good. Quaint and peaceful... Very nice!!

Extremely charming, boutique hotel, with modern interior design, but with the external antique perfectly kept design look of Edgartown. We visited off-season, in April, with almost no one at the town, and loved it!

We decided to go to Marthas Vineyard spur of the moment and were able to get a room at Kelley House! The room was every bit as nice as the pictures on-line looked! It was in a GREAT location - close enough to walk to some of the local attractions (light house w.in 10 min walk) & restaurants w.in 5 min walk but also the Newes Pub right there at hotel was wonderful and on-site parking! The staff we met - Bonnie and Mariana and Donnie - were friendly and informative! They could not have been more accommodating! It was great to have the morning coffee & fresh warm muffins available in the lobby (YUMMY). We can’t wait to go back! We definitely recommend this hotel!

This is a perfect location within walking distance to main shopping and dinning areas of Edgartown. Located next to the dock for the Chappy Ferry. The rooms are lovely. We were in 201 with 2 queen beds overlooking the main street. Room and bathroom looked newly renovated and very clean. Hotel staff were excellent. They bring out cookies and hot beverages in afternoon and muffins in morning. Outside has lovely pool (we went in October so closed) with areas to sit and relax. Other reviews had mentioned the thin walls and noise. This is the only drawback we found. Since we were on 2nd floor, we could hear everything in the room above us and folks talking in hallways. Since we went in October, the hotel wasn't full so I can imagine it must be very loud in summer. This would not deter me from returning, however. The overall location, comfort and accommodating staff far outweigh the noise.

Kelly Street Edgartown MA

Hotel highlights

  • Free WiFi and wired Internet in rooms and public areas
  • Free parking
  • Onsite dining
  • Outdoor pool

The Kelley House places you within a 15-minute stroll of popular sights such as Edgartown Lighthouse and Lighthouse Beach. This 57-room, 3-star hotel has private in-room pools along with an outdoor pool and free in-room WiFi.


Dining

You can enjoy a drink at the bar/lounge or visit the onsite restaurant for a bite to eat.


Rooms

All 57 rooms provide private pools, refrigerators, and coffee makers. 27-inch TVs come with digital channels, and guests can stay connected with free WiFi and wired Internet. Bathrooms offer hair dryers and designer toiletries, and pillowtop beds with premium bedding ensure a restful night. Other amenities include phones, ironing boards, and desks.


Property features

Guests of The Kelley House enjoy an outdoor pool, free WiFi in public areas, and a seasonal outdoor pool. If you drive, take advantage of free parking. Front-desk staff can assist with luggage storage, tours or tickets, and securing valuables. Additional amenities include coffee/tea in a common area, express check-out, and a garden.

Room options

Exclusive Suite, 1 King Bed

1 King Bed | Sleeps 2

Classic Room, 1 Bedroom, Kitchen, Ground Floor

2 King Beds and 1 Queen Sofa Bed | Sleeps 4

Standard Suite, 1 King Bed

1 King Bed | Sleeps 2

Classic Room, 1 Bedroom, Ground Floor

1 King Bed and 1 Queen Sofa Bed | Sleeps 4

Guest reviews for The Kelley House

Everyone (14) Couples (2) Family (5)
5
Family

Staff was amazing!

By on May 17, 2021

Review comment responded on May 23, 2021

Hi there, thank you very much for your feedback. Our team is always delighted to hear when a guest enjoyed his stay. We hope to welcome you back soon.

5
Family

Amusing. Everything very clean. The people very nice.

By , from Newton MA on Aug 14, 2020

Review comment responded on Sep 21, 2020

Thank you

1
Family

Terrible check in time. Arrived early was told I would be on the early check in list. Did not get to check in till well after 4pm. To add to the insult, the next day kept getting harassed to be out by 11am.

By , from Texas on Jul 29, 2020

Review comment responded on Aug 9, 2020

Thank you for your comments. We are sorry that you felt hurried at all. The actions we need to take during COVID require extended periods of time in the room for servicing. We hope you will understand.

5
Family with small children Family

I’ve stayed in many places on the Vineyard over the years, but this has got to be the very best! I arrived early due to my flight and the staff let me check in early. The room was perfect! The beds were comparable to diamon-level accommodations I’ve enjoyed on the past. The locale was perfect as I did not need to drive anywhere being that this was in the center of everything beautiful that Martha’s Vineyard has to offer. The best quality about this hotel: the staff. They are genuine, welcoming, and professional. I look forward to staying here again.

By on Jan 31, 2020

Review comment responded on Feb 3, 2020

Thank you for the wonderful review. We are so pleased you enjoyed your visit. We wish you safe travels and please come again soon.

4
Everyone

By on Nov 4, 2019

Review comment responded on Nov 5, 2019

Thank you for the review. Looks like you had a nice visit. The island is beautiful at this time of year to be sure. See you next time. Safe travels.

5
Everyone

By on Oct 4, 2019

Review comment responded on Oct 9, 2019

Thank you for thew great review. Your feedback is important to us!!

5
Partner Couples

Location and style was perfect for MV. Affordable and restaurant was good too.

By on Oct 2, 2019

Review comment responded on Oct 3, 2019

Thank you for the great review. We are glad you enjoyed the visit. See you next time!

5
Partner Couples

Great location, with pool and bar. Walking distance to great shops and restaurants.

By on Jul 1, 2019

Review comment responded on Jul 2, 2019

Thank you for the 5/5/ review. Safe trip home and we look forward to welcoming you back again soon.

5
Family

This was our second year staying at Kelley House with our 2 sons and one of their girlfriends(in their 20's)-it's a beautiful hotel, old and charming, but modern and stylish inside(think Serena and Lily). The location is ideal-walking distance to the Falmouth ferry, movie theater, Lighthouse Beach, and all shops and restaurants in Edgartown. The rooms are spacious and nicely decorated, and always had plenty of towels, bathroom items etc. Nice added touch are the muffins/coffee in the am and cookies/tea in the evening. The staff here is always wonderful and helpful...highly recommend! One tip:For guests renting bikes from the shop down the road, it would be great if the hotel rack could be relocated someplace that doesn't get flooded from the rain and if the hotel would cover those bikes with tarps at night as well. We'd be happy to rent them from the hotel if they provided bikes with more speeds for really cruising around the island.

By on Jun 25, 2019

Review comment responded on Jun 29, 2019

Thank you for the wonderful 5/5 review. We are thrilled that you took the time to highlight your experience. Please visit again soon.

5
Everyone

Very nice! Close to everything. Convenient parking.

By on Nov 19, 2018

Review comment responded on Nov 19, 2018

Thank you for taking the time to post and a 5/5 review. Thanks also for staying with us!! See you next time on the Vineyard.

url importing http://www.orbitz.com/Edgartown-Hotels-The-Kelley-House.h65623-p2.Hotel-Reviews
There was an error importing /Edgartown-Hotels-The-Kelley-House.h65623-p2.Hotel-Reviews, error: javax.servlet.jsp.JspTagException: 301 http://www.orbitz.com/Edgartown-Hotels-The-Kelley-House.h65623-p2.Hotel-Reviews

Frequently asked questions