Skip to main content
Beginning of main content

Newark Garden Hotel

2.5 out of 5.0

Recent guest reviews

Will never go there again. It's too far from the Finger Lakes, and there's nothing in the area.

Location is good between casino's. Staff is very friendly.

Room was clean but dated , breakfast was free and generous .

Large room, comfortable beds, very quiet setting. Had a great breakfast buffet to start the morning.

Good breakfast. Friendly staff. Good location for us because we were meeting friends in Newark.

Good room..comfy beds..good price..good location. .pool out of service..

It was great and excellent experience. Doesn't get any better for this price.

Everything great and Cheap! Location, breakfast.........

The experience wasn't good at all ,the hotel is old not taken care off the room was so cold because the heater wasn't working they changed the room for us but we had the same problem which means that the heating system is old and in a bad condition we slept with our jackets on and our kids were freezing The breakfast was fine but they had expired food in the baskets( yogurt) I will never visit this hotel again It's the worst hotel I've ever seen and visited

Just ordinary and over priced. $120.00 per night for not much.

Dirty towels from previous guests were still in the shower. Ice machine did not work. The floor was very dirty with very visible trash. Desk staff were so serious. They appeared angry. The bed sheets appeared slept on. The room was over 100 degrees upon arrival. It took about 4 hours to cool it down. The breakfast was very good. The staff was attentive. Good job.

very quiet with nice bar/lounge

The staff was very accommodating and efficient.

Very nice location; attractive property. The room was large and very nice with plenty of towels plus the extras (shampoo and conditioner). The wall-mounted hair dryer was convenient, and we enjoyed the coffee pot. The heated indoor pool was absolutely FREEZING and we could not stay in it; in the exercise room most of the equipment was broken and out of order. If you don't care about the pool or exercise room, this is a very nice place to stay.

Room options

Standard Room, 1 King Bed, Non Smoking

King 1 | Sleeps 2

Standard Room, 1 King Bed, Smoking

King 1 | Sleeps 2

Standard Room, 2 Double Beds, Non Smoking

Full 2 | Sleeps 4

Guest reviews for Newark Garden Hotel

Everyone (3) Business (4) Couples (3) Family (3) Other (1)
2

out of the way from the finger lakes and outdated.

Everyone

Will never go there again. It's too far from the Finger Lakes, and there's nothing in the area.

By , from Long Island on Aug 28, 2017

4
Everyone

Location is good between casino's. Staff is very friendly.

By on Jul 4, 2017

3

adequate average place enhanced by friendly staff

BusinessTravelers

Room was clean but dated , breakfast was free and generous .

By , from Rkchester NY on Oct 5, 2016

5

diamond in the rough

Everyone

Large room, comfortable beds, very quiet setting. Had a great breakfast buffet to start the morning.

By , from washington state on Aug 2, 2016

4

good rest

Couples

Good breakfast. Friendly staff. Good location for us because we were meeting friends in Newark.

By on Apr 1, 2015

3

nice people great location

Couples

Good room..comfy beds..good price..good location. .pool out of service..

By on Oct 20, 2014

5

fantastic stay

Families

It was great and excellent experience. Doesn't get any better for this price.

By on Sep 1, 2014

5

great stay

Families

Everything great and Cheap! Location, breakfast.........

By on Aug 2, 2014

1

not well maintained

Families

The experience wasn't good at all ,the hotel is old not taken care off the room was so cold because the heater wasn't working they changed the room for us but we had the same problem which means that the heating system is old and in a bad condition we slept with our jackets on and our kids were freezing The breakfast was fine but they had expired food in the baskets( yogurt) I will never visit this hotel again It's the worst hotel I've ever seen and visited

By on Nov 26, 2012

3

ok

BusinessTravelers

Just ordinary and over priced. $120.00 per night for not much.

By on Aug 13, 2012