Skip to main content
Beginning of main content

Recent guest reviews

Everyone was enjoyable at all levels of services. Plenty of amenities for you to keep busy and have a good time if it’s just you and your partner or it’s the whole family. Definitely somewhere we would stay again.

Nothing bad to say, very friendly! Nice place to stay.

This was a really clean place with a great owner. It's just a few blocks away from all the stuff Sister Bay has to offer. We really liked it.

Great outside fire pit. Free live music on Saturday from 4 to 6.

Have been going to door county for 60 years have stayed in a lot of houses and hotels this is the best hotel that I have been in yet extremely family friendly and can bring your dog it seems like they are always upgrading to make the place even better run by a family it's the best I've been to in door county

I had a confirmation from them.Then resort calls me few hours later to say sorry we booked room and we are full so sorry .I said I have a confirmation she replied we have no rooms available sir sorry and I said we are like 5 mins away we are driving she said sorry and she hung up.If that is how they run their business I am surprised they are in business .But it's Door County and no chain hotels are there. They are mostly individual businesses so they figure what's one upset customer who a tourist anyway type philosophy.

The setting was great - had a fire pit in the backyard and it was blazing to be enjoyed by everyone. Free breakfast was nice. Room was very comfortable. Very pleasant stay.

Very clean and friendly staff. Right off main highway but quiet

Very nice owners. Nice property. Son loved the pool.

We loved the accommodations at this hotel. There was so much more included than at some of the other local hotels. Beautiful outdoor area to grill out and eat, along with an area to frolf, play bags, and sit around the campfire. The included breakfast was just enough. They also provide board games and other amenities, as well as a little “shop” you can purchase snacks and other things you may need. The only bad thing I have to say about this hotel was our bathroom was small.

Very friendly staff. Beautiful patio with grill and fire pit

Nice hotel. Clean, comfortable, and attractive. Could provide a bit better breakfast.

Room very comfortable and quiet. Staff was very friendly and helpful with info on the area. Location is good for exploring the area. Close to so many things. Pretty setting. Outdoor areas. Nice pool and whirlpool. Have games and such for guests. Would definitely stay here again.

Pancakes were good but would be nice to add fruit and yogurt

Easy to find, on the outer limit of Sister Bay so it was quiet but right on the route to everything. The staff was nice and accommodating. You can appreciate the family owned business side of it all. Would stay again

Had to make a quick trip to DC and spent a night. Great bed and room was spotless. Manager on duty was very helpful. Definitely will use again.

S Bay Shore Drive Sister Bay WI

Hotel highlights

  • Walking distance to Lake Michigan
  • Free continental breakfast
  • Free WiFi in rooms and public areas
  • Free parking

Open Hearth Lodge places you next to Bay Ridge Golf Course and within a 10-minute walk of Frykman Studio Gallery. This 40-room hotel has free breakfast along with conveniences like an indoor pool and free in-room WiFi.


Dining

Free continental breakfast is included with your stay and awaits you each morning from 7:30 AM to 10 AM.


Rooms

TVs come with cable channels, and free WiFi keeps guests connected. Other amenities include refrigerators, hair dryers, and ironing boards.


Property features

Guests of Open Hearth Lodge have access to an indoor pool, a gym, and a sauna. If you plan to drive, free parking is available. Front-desk staff can help with luggage storage, and provide local restaurant recommendations. If you like to take your furry friend along on your adventures, this pet-friendly property offers food and water bowls and an off-leash area. Additional amenities include free WiFi in public areas, a spa tub, and a computer station.

Room options

Premium Room, 1 King Bed with Sofa bed, Jetted Tub

1 King Bed and 1 Twin Sofa Bed | Sleeps 5

Premium Room, 1 King Bed (No Pets)

1 King Bed | Sleeps 5

Lodge King Bed (No Pet)

1 King Bed | Sleeps 2

Lodge 2 Queen beds (No Pets)

2 Queen Beds | Sleeps 4

Guest reviews for Open Hearth Lodge

Everyone (12) Couples (6) Family (3)
5
Partner Couples

Everyone was enjoyable at all levels of services. Plenty of amenities for you to keep busy and have a good time if it’s just you and your partner or it’s the whole family. Definitely somewhere we would stay again.

By on Feb 11, 2024

Review comment responded on Feb 15, 2024

Thank you for the review, Anthony. I am so happy you enjoyed the stay and look forward to having you back sometime. :)

5
Everyone

Nothing bad to say, very friendly! Nice place to stay.

By on Oct 10, 2023

Review comment responded on Oct 10, 2023

Thank you, Constance. I am happy to hear your stay was excellent and look forward to seeing you back this way sometimes. :)

5
Family

This was a really clean place with a great owner. It's just a few blocks away from all the stuff Sister Bay has to offer. We really liked it.

By on Jun 19, 2023

Review comment responded on Jun 21, 2023

I appreciate the review. I hope to see you folks back up this way again soon.

5
Everyone

By on Jun 17, 2023

Review comment responded on Jul 7, 2023

Thank you for the review!

5
Partner Couples

Great outside fire pit. Free live music on Saturday from 4 to 6.

By on Apr 11, 2022

Review comment responded on Apr 14, 2022

Thank you for the review! The feedback is much appreciated!

4
Everyone

By on Sep 14, 2021

5
Partner Couples

Have been going to door county for 60 years have stayed in a lot of houses and hotels this is the best hotel that I have been in yet extremely family friendly and can bring your dog it seems like they are always upgrading to make the place even better run by a family it's the best I've been to in door county

By on Jul 24, 2021

Review comment responded on Jul 26, 2021

Thank you for your kind words. My family takes great pride in this place and is always looking to improve. We hope to see you again.

1
Partner Couples

I had a confirmation from them.Then resort calls me few hours later to say sorry we booked room and we are full so sorry .I said I have a confirmation she replied we have no rooms available sir sorry and I said we are like 5 mins away we are driving she said sorry and she hung up.If that is how they run their business I am surprised they are in business .But it's Door County and no chain hotels are there. They are mostly individual businesses so they figure what's one upset customer who a tourist anyway type philosophy.

By , from Appleton on Aug 14, 2020

Review comment responded on Aug 15, 2020

We are sorry for the inconvenience this caused you. We had one cancellation and 2 bookings for it at the same time. This occurred at check in, after taking care of the customers in front of me, I called you. This was 35 minutes from the email reservation I received. The online partners send confirmations automatically and if there is a mistake, we don't have a chance to change it. This is unpleasant for us as well. Computers are helpful but difficult at times. We hope you did enjoy your time in Door County.

5
Everyone

By on Dec 5, 2019

Review comment responded on Dec 26, 2019

Thanks for taking the time to provide us the feedback!!

5
Partner Couples Family

The setting was great - had a fire pit in the backyard and it was blazing to be enjoyed by everyone. Free breakfast was nice. Room was very comfortable. Very pleasant stay.

By on Oct 31, 2019

Review comment responded on Nov 2, 2019

Glad you enjoyed your stay. We hope you come our way again. Thanks for taking time to review us.

url importing http://www.orbitz.com/Sister-Bay-Hotels-Open-Hearth-Lodge.h9846724-p2.Hotel-Reviews
There was an error importing /Sister-Bay-Hotels-Open-Hearth-Lodge.h9846724-p2.Hotel-Reviews, error: javax.servlet.jsp.JspTagException: 301 http://www.orbitz.com/Sister-Bay-Hotels-Open-Hearth-Lodge.h9846724-p2.Hotel-Reviews

Frequently asked questions