Bay Shore hotels

Room 1
*Ages of children at time of trip (for pricing, discounts)

What travelers to Bay Shore are saying

Bay Shore is conveniently located to Long island Beaches
Richard R. May 22, 2015


Earn up to 5% on hotels and 1% on flights - It's free!

By clicking, I agree to the terms and conditions.

Hotels in Bay Shore

Oh, the things you'll see in Bay Shore. Between Blydenburgh Park, Connetquot River State Park and Bethpage Ballpark, you may never get bored.

You may, however, need to rest your tired feet (and head). That's where Orbitz's 60 hotels come in. Most rate highly for Hotel Staff and Room cleanliness, meaning you'll have little trouble finding a nice, cozy room to tuck into — as near or as far from the action as you'd like.

Get outdoors in Bay Shore

Not all of Bay Shore's attractions are indoors. Spend some time at Blydenburgh Park. Visiting Calf Pasture Beach, too, is a good way to get outside.

Dive deep into marine biology and meet some of the creatures that live in the water at Suffolk County Fish & Reef.

Activities and entertainment in Bay Shore

Whether you're traveling solo or with the entire family in tow, you can find something fun to do in Bay Shore. Hit the rides at Pump It Up before filling up on indulgent treats. For a different kind of rush, catch a game or concert at Bethpage Ballpark.

Elite Laser Hair Removal is always on hand to help you relax and forget about work for a while.

Where to eat in Bay Shore

Few experiences are as satisfying as a good, hearty meal. Luckily, that's easy to find in Bay Shore — just grab a table at Applebee's, Lakeland Pizzeria, Mc Guire's Comedy Club & Restaurant and Dunkin' Donuts and tuck in.

Where to shop in Bay Shore

While traveling, not all events are planned, but Bay Shore has you covered. Pick up new clothes or any forgotten essentials at Browse 'n' Buy Mail Order Market, Walmart and Walmart.

Jewelry stores like East Islip Jewelers and electronics stores like Best Buy are on hand for picking up gifts, the latest tech gadgets and more.

Nightlife in Bay Shore

Spice up your trip with a foray into Bay Shore's nightlife scene. The staff at Brickyard Bar & Grill, Barracks and Island Gamers Club open their doors to patrons looking for a cold brew or mixed drink. Ample sports coverage or dancing may not be hard to find, either.

Arts and culture in Bay Shore

Put a little culture on your itinerary in Bay Shore. The exhibits at Lake Ronkonkoma Historical Soc are good places to soak it in and do some people watching.

You can also learn a thing or two while exploring Bay Shore — just dive into the books at Central Islip Public Library and Barnes & Noble. The knowledge-filled halls and campus of Dowling College, University Support Services and Adelphi College Suffolk Division may be worthy of a tour.

Best times to visit Bay Shore

Want to save up to 26%, 24% and 21% while traveling to Bay Shore? If you book on Orbitz and travel during February, January and March, respectively, you can. So get out there and experience something new — for less!

Getting to Bay Shore

If you're flying in, head for Long Island MacArthur Airport — it's one of Bay Shore's main transportation hubs.

Recently Rated Bay Shore Hotels

Hotel Reviews Stars Price from
Bay Shore Inn
2.3 / 5
4 reviews
1 star $94
Red Carpet Inn Bay Shore
2.1 / 5
12 reviews
2 stars Choose dates

Featured Bay Shore Hotels

From $84

1 BEST WESTERN Woodbury Inn

3 stars
3.4 / 5 84 reviews

7940 Jericho Turnpike

Save 20% on your stay

Mornings at the pet-friendly Best Western Woodbury Inn begin with a free deluxe continental breakfast featuring make-your-own waffles in a bright, wood-floored dining area. Spend some time at the...

Nice, clean, and friendly.
The hotel and staff did a great job to make our stay special. We recommend this hotel and plan to stay there again.
Nov 5, 2015
From $132

2 Residence Inn Long Island Holtsville

3 stars
Not yet reviewed

25 Middle Avenue

At the Residence Inn Long Island Holtsville, enjoy spacious studio and one-bedroom suites that are 50% larger than traditional hotel rooms. Our suites offer separate living, eating and sleeping...

From $105

3 Comfort Inn Medford

2 stars
3.6 / 5 21 reviews

2695 Route 112

Conveniently located on the Long Island Expressway at Exit 64. Short drive to ocean, beaches, outlet shopping and Long Islands East End attractions and wineries. Minutes from Long Island McCarthur...

Very nice
It was very clean and the staff was very friendly me and my family felt like we was home
Nov 17, 2015
From $105

4 Extended Stay America - Long Island - Melville

2 stars
3.5 / 5 34 reviews

100 Spagnoli Rd

At Extended Stay America, only 20 miles from Long Island, guests find a friendly home away from home whether they stay a day, a week or a month. Fully equipped kitchens in each of our 133 spacious...

...a good hotel.
I had a good stay considering the high price of other hotels in the area.
Nov 17, 2015
From $156

5 Hampton Inn Long Island-Commack

3 stars
4.3 / 5 36 reviews

680 Commack Rd.

Free On The House hot breakfast, Wi-Fi

an island town in the center of it all...welcome to the Hampton Inn Long Island/Commack.Long Island is home to beaches, historic homes, great shopping, and fabulous dining. When you stay at our...

Clean, quiet, breakfast we very good. Maybe more fruit
Nov 13, 2015
From $124

6 Residence Inn Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex

3 stars
4.5 / 5 4 reviews

7 Court House Dr

The NEW Residence Inn Long Island Islip Courthouse Complex, is the extended-stay hotel, conveniently located to the Cohalan Courthouse Plaza, Central Islip, Touro Law School, Bethpage Ballpark,...

It was nice room was fairly clean the pool was enjoyable the staff was nice but some was rude
Dec 17, 2015

7 Red Carpet Inn Bay Shore

2 stars
2.1 / 5 12 reviews

501 East Main Street

Additional area points of interest include Robert Moses State Park/ Atlantis Marine World aquarium/ Splish Splash water park and Long Island Wineries. The Long Island MacArthur Airport is only 10...

Great location
The staff was very polite and courteous. Room was neat and clean. One thing I noticed that was not accurate was that in some of the online sites it mentioned mini-bar, but it was just a fridge....
Jun 9, 2014
From $62

8 Jones Beach Hotel

3 stars
4.0 / 5 1 reviews

3275 Byron Street

Stay tonight Save 20%

Located 16 miles from John F Kennedy International Airport, this Wantagh hotel offers a transfer service to the airport and is 9 minutes' drive from Jones Beach State Park. Free Wi-Fi is...

No beach at Jones'
Hotel was very nice. A bit old and in need of some repairs but staff and room were very pleasant. Great value and the room was well kept.
Oct 25, 2015
From $109

9 Red Roof PLUS Long Island

2 stars
3.5 / 5 114 reviews

699 Dibblee Dr

Save 10% on your stay

Red Roof Inn Garden City - Long Island, New York is a pet friendly, family friendly hotel close to Hofstra University, Jones Beach and Nassau County Aquatic Center on Long Island. This clean, newly...

Quick trip
Good place to stay. A lot nearby. Quick stay. Clean, simple. Nice staff.
Dec 6, 2015
From $120

10 Upsky Long Island Hotel

3 stars
3.4 / 5 12 reviews

110 Vanderbilt Motor Parkway

Just off the Long Island Expressway in the Hauppauge Industrial Park, Upsky Long Island Hotel makes business travel easy and convenient. The coffee shop opens early, the restaurant serves dinner...

solo stay
Friendly staff great pool. Rooms were Clea and comfortable.
Sep 30, 2015
From $133

11 Courtyard by Marriott Republic Airport Long Island/Farmingdale

3 stars
4.3 / 5 24 reviews

Two Marriott Plaza

Rate includes breakfast

The Courtyard by Marriott Long Island/Farmingdale is the newest Marriott hotel serving the Farmingdale/Melville Route 110 Corporate Corridor. Newly renovated with a customer focused design that...

Stay for a Funeral
Took a long time to get checked in even though it was 10:30 pm and three staff members at the front desk including the manager. Hotel stay was ok. My room key didn't work on the outside door and...
Nov 1, 2015
From $94

12 La Quinta Inn & Suites Islip MacArthur Airport

3 stars
4.0 / 5 97 reviews

10 Aero Rd

Less than a mile from Islip MacArthur Airport, the La Quinta Inn & Suites Islip MacArthur Airport hotel offers free airport shuttle service. Our Stay & Go package rates include shuttle service to...

Family Wedding in the area
I needed a pet friendly hotel and La Quinta was accommodating and very near the reception/restaurant. I would definitely stay there again. More hotels should allow pets and La Quinta was very...
Sep 16, 2015
From $92

13 Comfort Inn Syosset

2 stars
4.6 / 5 10 reviews

24 Oak Drive

The Comfort Inn Syosset has added several new and exciting amenities. Our great room style lobby now has a full service lobby bar. Unwind after a long day or meet up with friends and colleagues....

4's instead of 5's
The stay was excellent... everything was advertised. I only used the 4's because I think if we put all 5's there's no room for any improvement, which there always is. The only down side was the...
Dec 5, 2015
From $155

14 Hyatt Regency Long Island

4 stars
3.8 / 5 53 reviews

1717 Motor Pkwy

Stay More Save More. Up to 15% off 2nts or more.

Golf fans find a fast friend in Hyatt Regency Long Island. On the same property sits the Steven Kay-designed Hamlet Wind Watch Golf Club, an 18-hole, par-71 championship golf course managed by PGA...

Comfortable trip
Overall clean room. Nice people. Food is okay could be a little better for the price.
Dec 16, 2015
From $113

15 Hilton Garden Inn Islip / MacArthur Airport

3 stars
4.1 / 5 40 reviews

3485 Veterans Memorial Highway

Complimentary wired and Wi-Fi Internet Access

Decor is not an afterthought at Hilton Garden Inn Islip /MacArthur Airport. Step into an elegant lobby with fireplaces and sage green armchairs, just right for reading or conversation. A shuttle...

A night out
My friends and I crashed here for the night for fun. The hotel was nice, it had a fridge. Only thing was that there was a bug in the bed and when we told the front desk clerk he didnt seem to care...
Dec 4, 2015
From $120

16 Holiday Inn Express HAUPPAUGE-LONG ISLAND

3 stars
3.8 / 5 35 reviews

2050 Express Drive South

Part of a chain known for comfortable budget rooms, Holiday Inn Express HAUPPAUGE -- LONG ISLAND lives up to the promise. The lobby great room and library with a working fireplace, overstuffed...

girls night out
Yes we did enjoy our stay. The free breakfast was delicious and the pool felt amazing
Oct 8, 2015
From $178

17 Melville Marriott Long Island

3 stars
3.5 / 5 21 reviews

1350 Walt Whitman Road

Rate includes breakfast

The largest full-service hotel in Suffolk County is the smoke-free Melville Marriott Long Island. Located three miles from Huntington/Melville Corporate Parks, this business-friendly hotel with...

Business Trip
Hotel was great for quick stay. Staff was efficient and friendly. For these kid of room rates, internet should be included.
Nov 7, 2015
From $110

18 Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia

3 stars
3.9 / 5 43 reviews

1600 Veterans Memorial Highway

Free On The House hot breakfast, Wi-Fi

pull off the expressway and relax...welcome to the Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia.Fun abounds near the Hampton Inn® hotel in Long Island/Islandia. Explore a Charles II-style English mansion. Tour...

Comfortable and convenient
Comfortable and clean room. Pillows were way too soft! Housekeeping was great and friendly when asked for extra towels. Liked the 24 hour tea and coffee. Everyone was very friendly and helpful.
Dec 8, 2015
From $102

19 Hampton Inn Long Island-Brookhaven

3 stars
4.0 / 5 37 reviews

2000 North Ocean Avenue

Free On The House hot breakfast, Wi-Fi

Get off to a delicious start with a free hot breakfast buffet at Hampton Inn Long Island – Brookhaven. Served in the great room complete with a 42-inch flat-screen TV and fireplace, choices include...

More space than expected
We needed a room for a family trip and in particular one with a decent fridge. The suite we got was much larger and nicer than I had expected for the price we paid. The staff was very friendly and...
Nov 28, 2015
From $106

20 Courtyard by Marriott Long Island MacArthur Airport

3 stars
4.1 / 5 55 reviews

5000 Express Drive South

Rate includes breakfast

Boasting a central location, excellent amenities, and spacious accommodations, the Courtyard Long Island MacArthur Airport is an excellent hotel choice for visitors to Ronkonkoma, New York. Close...

holiday visit
Staff was lovely and friendly, room was clean and BIG! Lots of room for 2 adults with 2 teenagers! Free wifi - (kids loved this!) I only wish there had been a free continental breakfast. . .a...
Jan 1, 2016