Hotel St. Croix ★★★

3.3 /5
Overall score
83%
Would recommend
Amenities:
3
Cleanliness:
4.6
Hotel staff:
3.8
Comfort:
4.3
Location:
4
Value:
3.9
1 2 3 4 5

Select your room

Overview

Twenty three uniquely designed and furnished guest rooms have been refurbished, refurnished, outfitted with safes, flat screen TV's, in-room Internet access, fans and air-conditioning. It was built for a Danish doctor and has been considered one of St. Croix's oldest building and one of the first hotels.

The Club Comanche Hotel is considered a historical hotel and bar. Built during the 1750s, it has been restored and refurbished to provide you with modern amenities.

For your convenience and in order to better serve you, please contact at 1-866-975-2927 at least 24 hours prior to your arrival and advise your expected arrival time at the hotel.

Recommendations for you

Guest score 4.0 / 5
$277
Guest score 3.5 / 5
$119
Guest score 3.0 / 5
$130
Guest score 3.9 / 5
$195
Guest score 3.9 / 5
$255

The Buccaneer

★★★★★
Guest score 4.4 / 5
$397

Amenities

Featured

  • WiFi
  • Outdoor pool
  • No smoking rooms/facilities

General

  • No smoking rooms/facilities

Activities

  • Outdoor pool

Dining

  • Bar/Lounge

Services

  • Conference facilities

Internet

  • WiFi

Reviews

3.3 /5 Overall score

83% Would recommend

  • Amenities: 3/5
  • Cleanliness: 4.6/5
  • Hotel staff: 3.8/5
  • Comfort: 4.3/5
  • Location: 4/5
  • Value: 3.9/5

40th Anniversary Celebratiion

Would recommend Sun, Jul 28, 2013
Our plane was 2 hours late for arrival in St. Croix. "Carmen" kept the light on for us - (literally) and greeted us at the door with a chilled bottle of champaigne. The services we received were outstanding. All the staff were kind and attentive to assist us in any way they could - even helping us to track down our lost luggage. The location was very close to the boardwalk - no car needed - taxi service was just a step away. The room was very clean. I would recommend Club Comanche to anyone going to St. Croix. The only change to the "Run of the House" would be adding a microwave to the room.

Shopping hint

Lovely little shopping stores. Stores are not open on Sunday's or Monday's unless cruise ship docks and then you might catch a few open. But go out and EXPLORE. NO sales tax either.

| Ohio Couples

5 /5

Overall score
  • Amenities: 4 /5
  • Cleanliness: 5 /5
  • Hotel staff: 5 /5
  • Comfort: 5 /5
  • Location: 5 /5
  • Value: 5 /5

Disappointed

Would recommend Tue, Feb 5, 2013
The smoke detector had been ripped off the wall. When this was brought up to the clerk at the front desk, she said that she could not help me and that there were no rooms available. I then showed her that this site said there were multiple. She then quickly told me that yes they were empty but they were not ready... She then moved us to a room that had a smoke detector, a fridge, and a king size bed. The first room had none of these. There was no parking available at the hotel, which was not a problem we can walk, but for someone who has difficulties I would not suggest it. After arriving we signed in and climbed a few flights of stairs. The historical tropical view room, was a room and a bathroom that is all. Not a problem, however there was no tropical view.

| Norfolk, VA Friends

3 /5

Overall score
  • Amenities: 2 /5
  • Cleanliness: 5 /5
  • Hotel staff: 1 /5
  • Comfort: 2 /5
  • Location: 4 /5
  • Value: 3 /5

Good Location

Would recommend Fri, Nov 23, 2012
Great place, near board walk and in center of the town and stores

Nightlife hint

Walk to boardwalk and make bar hopping

| San Juan, PR Business

4 /5

Overall score
  • Amenities: 3 /5
  • Cleanliness: 5 /5
  • Hotel staff: 2 /5
  • Comfort: 5 /5
  • Location: 5 /5
  • Value: 4 /5

Great to be in St. Croix

Would recommend Fri, Nov 2, 2012
Great Centric location Near the board walk and many pubs with nightlife In the center of the town Pool was damage and water green!! That the only thing, they have problems with the contractor... but hey the beach is so near!!

Nightlife hint

Make bar hopping!!! From Angry nate until Christian Brew Pub and good night life..

| San Juan, PR Business

3 /5

Overall score
  • Amenities: 2 /5
  • Cleanliness: 5 /5
  • Hotel staff: 5 /5
  • Comfort: 5 /5
  • Location: 4 /5
  • Value: 5 /5

Very nice, great location

Would recommend Mon, Jul 23, 2012
Very nice accomadtions and personel very friendly. Great location to dining, stores and beaches

| NJ Singles

4 /5

Overall score
  • Amenities: 3 /5
  • Cleanliness: 5 /5
  • Hotel staff: 5 /5
  • Comfort: 5 /5
  • Location: 4 /5
  • Value: 4 /5

Noisy

Would not recommend Sat, Dec 24, 2011
In spite of every efforts made to renovate the rooms, this hotel remains an rickety colonial building in the heart of the boardwalk area peppered with bars. Great if you're in a party mood, but not if you need to sleep. Not to mention the roosters outside your window who will make sure you wake up at 5AM.

| Montreal Business

2 /5

Overall score
  • Amenities: 3 /5
  • Cleanliness: 4 /5
  • Hotel staff: 3 /5
  • Comfort: 3 /5
  • Location: 1 /5
  • Value: 2 /5

club comanche st croix

Would recommend Sun, Dec 19, 2010
I stayed with my girlfriend in the jr suit with a king size bed. It was awesome. No it is not a brand new building like i am used to in minneapolis mn but it was had gorgeous dark wood floor that maids mop everyday to keep clean. they dont change your sheets everyday like a hilton but they save energy and water by skipping a day. yes they dont change them between people. the staff are very friendly and there is a guy named [...] and he is 10 times more of a help and nicer then any hilton or ramada employee ive ever talked to. the hotel is located a block down from the ocean and center of the shopping and resturants. it is great location and great experience. i will be going back.

Attractions

you better like swimming. there is nothing for you if you dont like sailing, jet skis or snorkling.

| chaska, mn Couples

4 /5

Overall score
  • Amenities: 4 /5
  • Cleanliness: 4 /5
  • Hotel staff: 5 /5
  • Comfort: 5 /5
  • Location: 5 /5
  • Value: 4 /5

Not what it was cracked up to be

Would not recommend Wed, Oct 27, 2010
Unhelpful desk clerk at check in, and the room was difficult to get to with luggage (several sets of stairs and no one there to help). Newly remodeled room but already getting shabby (by not cleaning in the corners, not repairing furniture, etc.). We thought there was sand in the bed--turned out to be a termite problem. The pool couldn't be used because it leaked. The NOISE was awful--a party until after 3 in the hotel bar just outside our window on Saturday, with no warning except when the hotel clerk woke us up to give us free tickets to the event later that night. Complained to the front desk (repeatedly) but they simply said, "We left a message for the manager."

| Grand Rapids, Michigan Friends

1 /5

Overall score
  • Amenities: 1 /5
  • Cleanliness: 2 /5
  • Hotel staff: 2 /5
  • Comfort: 1 /5
  • Location: 2 /5
  • Value: 2 /5

Great family location

Would recommend Sun, Sep 19, 2010
This location lets you explore the historic fort dating from the 1750's. The boardwalk shouldn't be missed.

Shopping hint

Lots of great shops and dining. Especially check out the famous Blue Iguana.

| St Thomas Couples

4 /5

Overall score
  • Amenities: 4 /5
  • Cleanliness: 5 /5
  • Hotel staff: 4 /5
  • Comfort: 5 /5
  • Location: 5 /5
  • Value: 5 /5

Top hotels

Hotel Policies

  • Check-in: 3:00 PM
  • Check-out: 12:00 PM

Terms and conditions

Rates quoted in currencies other than the hotel's base currency are subject to the rate of the international exchange. Rate may change throughout stay. Rate may reflect average nightly rate. Extra charges may apply. Incidental charges, such as room service, are not included in the rate.

The amenities and/or facilities may not be located at the hotel, but within a reasonable distance, and additional charges may apply for use. All information has been provided by this hotel and not by Orbitz